Democratic institutions are less effective at
ensuring equality without special protection for
minorities. Any initiative in support of democratic governance should be cognizant of the
access and participation barriers that minorities
may face and work to overcome these barriers.
Two key factors are minority access to justice
and participation in governance.
Before proceeding, a caveat is required. The
relationship between the State and marginalised minorities is distinct in some ways from
the relationship between the State and other
marginalised groups. One of the main differences is political: minority groups are more likely
to be viewed by some governments as potential
political challengers than other groups. Ethnic,
religious and linguistic minorities, for example,
commonly form political parties, whereas women,
persons with disabilities or people living with
HIV do not. Governments could be supported to
create an environment where minorities can participate on an equal basis in political processes,
including strengthening institutions for political
freedom so that minority groups may form their
own (political) associations.
4.3.1 Access to Justice
Minorities often lack access to justice and equal
protection of the law due to discrimination.
Discrimination can occur in the various stages of
law enforcement, from interaction with police, to
presentation of court cases and sentencing, and
at higher levels of legislative drafting. Minorities
are more vulnerable to arbitrary arrests and are
less likely to receive a fair trial due to discrimination, under-representation in legal services,
higher levels of social exclusion and language
barriers. The absence of non-discrimination legislation and/or the lack of effective remedies
are common problems. It is important to recall
that the ICERD recognises the right of everyone
“to equal treatment before the tribunals and all
other organs administering justice” (article 5 (a))
without discrimination. This applies to all minorities, including migrant communities.
46
Policing:
In many societies, minorities may have a negative
relationship with the police. This may be due to discriminatory practices by the police, such as racial
profiling, low representation of minorities among
the police force, failure of the police to investigate
crimes committed against minorities and in some
cases violence by the police against minorities. The
cumulative effect is that trust and cooperation with
the police by minority groups is often very low.
There are several solutions for remedying this. The
police force could be monitored by the government to ensure that it is not violating the rights
of minorities, that it is fully implementing the laws
that protect minorities, and that it is investigating
and prosecuting crimes committed against minorities, without discrimination. Training on minority
rights and the factors of exclusion that affect
minorities may be offered and reviewed regularly.
The police could reflect the ethnic, religious and
linguistic composition of the population at large
and greater efforts to recruit and retain minority
women and men could be made. Institutionalized
racism could be addressed, for instance, with
appropriate monitoring and complaints systems.
Relations between the police and minority communities may be strengthened by partnership
agreements. Such partnerships could be forged
between local and national police, minority
CSOs and minority community representatives.
Such partnerships involve committed, long-term
trust building between the parties to ensure
mutual understanding, open communication and
transparency. Minority community liaison officers are a good tool but engagement could be
mainstreamed throughout law enforcement institutions at all levels. Overcoming prejudice and
distrust on the part of minorities and the police
will be a lengthy and sensitive process but is an
important step in building public confidence in
the law enforcement system. Given that the police
are often at the front line of managing inter-communal conflict, sensitising them to the rights of
minorities is also a vital part of conflict prevention.
M A R G I N A L I S E D M I N O R I T I E S I N D E V E LO P M E N T P R O G R A M M I N g