A/HRC/7/36
page 6
26. Regarding the racial equality index, Mr. Frans stated that one idea that needed to be part of
it should be whether States had ratified the relevant treaties and conventions with or without
reservations. This was practical information that should be included in the index.
Item 5 (a) (ii): Media
27. Mr. Frans, expert of the Working Group on People of African Descent, began his
presentation on the media by stressing the fact that the role of communication and media in the
process of development should not be underestimated. Most western media treated the cultures
of industrialized nations as superior and the cultures of the developing nations as inferior. The
media had enormous influence in shaping public perception of situations around the world. The
images of Africa in Western media were, by and large, images of misrepresentation. Media had a
responsibility and an obligation to combat racism. Thus, a code of conduct for the media was
needed.
28. Ms. Irina Moroianu-Zlătescu, member of the Working Group on People of African
descent, expressed her belief that the media had not only an important role to provide
information but also a certain responsibility. People always spoke of rights but not enough of
responsibilities. The role of the education and the training of the mass media were meant to
prevent discrimination.
29. A comment was made regarding the importance of the interconnection between media
and the administration of justice. An instance was provided in which the media were
irresponsible in their broadcasting; instead of relieving an already tense racial situation, they
heightened it by explicitly showing attack dogs mauling black Mozambique immigrants at the
South Africa/Mozambique border. The commentator further stressed the importance of the
media in general - not just the imbedded media - in being sensible with regard to the type of
imagery and content they chose to show.
30. An intervention was made regarding the actual possibility of creating a code of conduct for
journalists and, if possible, what would be the time frame for implementing such a code of
conduct and who would implement it.
31. Other commentators stressed that, though a code of conduct might have several question
marks regarding its implementation, it was imperative to begin work as one was long overdue.
The commentator stressed that there should be measures which recommend that the rights and
the reputation of persons should be protected. The commentator cited in particular a document
adopted at a 2007 Ministerial Conference on People of African Descent which asked that a code
of conduct be set up. The observer in that instance recalled Tony Blair’s reaction concerning the
well-known cartoons in the Danish newspapers, and stated that, although Mr. Blair had said
that although the cartoons were not illegal acts according to British law, there had to be some
self-restraint so as to avoid using freedom of expression as an excuse for insults.
32. There was general agreement that the nature of images presented by the media had been a
very important issue within the United Nations. It was stressed that that issue should be looked at
in a progressive manner and attempts should be made to balance freedom of expression with
attempts to reduce incitement of race and religious hatred. The particular importance of
regulating against hate media was stressed.