A/HRC/51/28/Add.1
39.
The peoples with whom the Special Rapporteur met reported that, in 2011, owing to
the lack of political will in State institutions to indemnify them for their lands, which is
demonstrated by, among other things, the failure to enact the bill on the autonomous
development of indigenous peoples and the ineffectiveness of the National Plan for the
Recovery of Indigenous Territories, they were obliged to start organized de facto requisitions
of their own lands, since those lands are their only means of earning a living and keeping
their culture alive.
40.
The Special Rapporteur is concerned about documented acts of violence, such as
threats against persons requisitioning lands and two murders of indigenous leaders (see
section D), which are under investigation. He is also worried about reported violations of the
right of access to basic services, such as water and electricity, on requisitioned plots of land.
41.
Indigenous peoples reiterated that requisitioned plots of land are their only source of
subsistence, all the more so during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. The
Special Rapporteur was able to see that development schemes have been implemented on the
requisitioned plots, fostering the recovery of indigenous identity and food self-sufficiency.
One example of this is the Crun Shurín plot in the Terraba territory, where sustainable
agriculture schemes support at least 26 families and 80 persons.
42.
The Special Rapporteur received worrying reports about the environmental and social
damage associated with monocultures and agrochemicals, for example, in the Canton of
Buenos Aires, including the contamination of soil and water by companies.
C.
Consultation and free, prior and informed consent
43.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the adoption by the Government of a mechanism
for consulting the indigenous peoples, intended to guarantee their right to free, prior and
informed consent and the effective protection of their collective rights. Executive Decree
No. 40932 was enacted in 2018, with the participation and consent of 22 indigenous
territories, and drafted following over 120 visits to indigenous territories. The decree
established the Technical Unit for Indigenous Consultation, the body of the Ministry of
Justice and Peace responsible for the technical and financial administration of indigenous
consultation processes and the indigenous territorial consultation bodies, the Government’s
indigenous counterpart and interlocutor in each indigenous territory. Each indigenous
territory appoints the members of its body on the basis of its own rules and representation
mechanisms.
44.
Although the Government has trained the staff of the Technical Unit for Indigenous
Consultation with the support of the United Nations system, more staff still need to be
recruited, the Unit’s capacity to duly handle all the requests for consultations still needs to be
enhanced and staff knowledge of indigenous peoples’ rights still needs to be improved. It is
also worrying that, in territories where there are no indigenous territorial consultation bodies,
consultations are conducted through comprehensive development associations.
45.
The Special Rapporteur notes that the consultation on the adoption of the draft public
policy for indigenous peoples was the first time that use had been made of the Government’s
General Mechanism for Consultation with Indigenous Peoples and will serve to evaluate its
effectiveness. The public policy for indigenous peoples will address important issues, such
as the recognition of indigenous autonomy and territoriality, self-development and wellbeing, the indigenous peoples’ social inclusion and institutional effectiveness in support for
indigenous peoples. The Special Rapporteur congratulates the Government of Costa Rica on
the progress it has made with the consultation, in particular in the Boruca territory, but
reminds the Government that the Mechanism must be implemented in full in all indigenous
territories.
46.
The Special Rapporteur recognizes that the other branches of government have
replicated this consultation mechanism for specific processes, such as Act No. 9710 and the
draft institutional policy on indigenous peoples’ access to justice. However, both the
Legislative Assembly and the judiciary need to set out their internal consultation procedures,
in coordination with indigenous peoples and in line with applicable human rights standards.
8
GE.22-11025