A/HRC/4/21/Add.1
page 73
guards or interrogators. The Government maintained its firm commitment to respect religious
freedom and it stated that the United States is particularly dedicated to respecting the religious
and cultural dignity of the Koran and the detainees’ practice of faith. The Joint Task Force has
carefully implemented a standard operating procedure that makes every effort to provide
detainees with religious articles associated with the Islamic faith, accommodate prayers and
religious periods, and provide culturally acceptable meals and practices.
310. The alleged instances of Koran mishandling were the focus of an in-depth investigation
that was launched on 5 May 2005. This investigation found no credible evidence that a member
of the Joint Task Force at Guantanamo Bay flushed a Koran down the toilet. An interview with
the detainee who reportedly made this allegation revealed that he was not a witness to any such
mistreatment and no other claims of this type have been made. The matter is therefore considered
closed.
311. Since the issuing of Korans to detainees in January 2002, there have been nineteen
incidents involving handling of the Koran by Joint Task Force personnel. Of these nineteen
incidences, ten involved the touching of a Koran during the normal performance of duty. The
other nine incidents involved intentional or unintentional mishandling of a Koran. General Hood,
who led the investigation, identified seven incidents where a guard may have mishandled a
Koran. In two additional instances (one confirmed) an interrogator may have mishandled a
Koran. The investigation also revealed fifteen cases in which the detainees themselves
mishandled or inappropriately treated the Koran.
312. With regard to the five instances of confirmed Koran mishandling the Joint Task Force
specifically found:
313. During an interrogation in February 2002, a detainee complained that guards at Camp Xray kicked the Koran of a detainee in a neighbouring cell. The interrogator reported the incident,
the guards were aware of the detainee’s complaint but there is no evidence of further
investigation.
314. On 15 August 2003, two detainees complained that their Korans were wet because the
night shift guards had thrown water balloons on the cell block. The complaints were recorded. It
has not been determined whether further complaints were made by the detainees or whether their
Korans were replaced. There is no evidence of further investigation into this incident.
315. On 21 August 2003, a detainee complained that a two-word obscenity had been scrawled
in English on the inside cover of his English-language Koran. The complaint was recorded and
the English-language Koran was taken from the detainee who retained his Arabic-language
Koran. There is no record of a formal complaint of the detainee to the commander.
316. On 25 March 2005 a detainee complained to his guards that urine came through an air
vent and splashed on him and his Koran while he lay near the air vent. A guard reported to his
cellblock commander that he was at fault since he had left his post to urinate outside and had
done so near the air vent so that the wind blew his urine into the air vent. The guard was relieved
of duty and the detainee was immediately issued with a fresh uniform and a new Koran.