A/HRC/11/7/Add.2
page 15
48. Migrant child labour is a pervasive phenomenon according to information received by the
Special Rapporteur. But government efforts, especially at the state level, seem not to be
commensurate with the high rates of its occurrence and the corrupt practices that permit its
continuance. The Special Rapporteur welcomes recent efforts by the state of Chiapas, for
example, to acknowledge the phenomenon and to combat it, but suggests that these efforts are
inadequate. Not only a shift in consciousness about the reality and severity of the violations, but
a more robust targeting of employers and recruiters, are in order. The first step is further
investigation regarding the extent that migrant child labour is being used.
D. Migrant women
49. Migrant women are particularly vulnerable in Mexico. They form the majority of cases of
harassment or abuse in detention, clandestine domestic workers (sometimes “servants”),
prostitutes, sexual abuse and physical and sexual assault in smuggling operations. They are also
the majority of victims of trafficking (the total estimated at 16,000 to 22,000 victims annually,
including children) and there are unusually high rates of homicides of women, especially in such
border towns as Ciudad Juárez. Those women migrants who enter Mexico regularly or find
decent work are often subject to a wage differential based on their sex, reported to be as much
as 40 per cent lower than men of the same skill level.
50. According to INM, women migrants detained and deported from Mexico represent
approximately 20 per cent of annual flows. While the majority of these women are from
Central America (Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador), some 5 per cent are from other
Latin America countries and various parts of the world. The average stay in Mexico for women
from Central America seems to be between two and seven days, while women from outside of
Central America stay longer, generally from two weeks to three months or more, depending on
their nationality, access to consular protection, and whether or not they had filed a legal claim.
51. According to reports from civil society organizations, there are recurrent incidents of
women being treated with violence or aggressively by INM personnel when being transferred to
detention centres and by staff upon arrival and during the duration of their stay. Some refer to
aggressive and discriminatory comments, and others report physical mistreatment. There are few
formal complaints, however, both because of fear of reprisal, or because there seems to be little
knowledge about how to lodge a formal complaint.
52. Medical assistance to migrants, especially female-specific, seems to be lacking in some
circumstances. Due to the stress that detention causes for women migrants, many become sick
upon arrival at the detention centre and some seek to attend to injuries or illnesses incurred
before or during the journey. Care and treatment related to sexual violence needs to be further
developed and offered more pervasively. IOM has a programme in Tapachula to fill this gap and
reports that there is a stigma attached to reporting incidences of sexual abuse. Although many
women migrants flee abuse of such a kind or experience it along the way, few programmes for
counselling or, more specifically, for victims of trafficking, exist.
53. There are also a small number of women asylum-seekers. According to INM figures
from 2007, a total of 40 women applied for asylum in Tapachula, among whom 23 were main
applicants. Four of these women were recognized as refugees; all four were Iraqi.