E/CN.4/1989/44
page 23
"Appointment to posts in both the voluntary and State sectors is by
way of open competition. Religious affiliation is not generally a
consideration in the filling of such posts. However, it is generally a
condition, either explicit or implicit, that staff employed in such
institutions will respect the ethical character of the institutions
concerned. It is in this respect that the contract of consultant medical
staff in certain public voluntary hospitals differs from the standard
conditions applicable throughout the State hospital sector. Such a
requirement can by no means be represented as requiring the individual so
appointed to forego his personal rights to freedom of conscience or of
expression. It follows that these conditions of employment cannot
represent intolerance or discrimination based on religion or belief.
Indeed were the conditions of employment to be otherwise, it is difficult
to see how the specific ethos of the hospitals in question could be
maintained. The Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of
Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief clearly
envisages at article 6 (b) that hospitals, as charitable or humanitarian
institutions, can be maintained by religious organizations. The State is
entitled as a matter of public policy to make use of the services
provided by such institutions on an equitable basis and to integrate
them into the system of delivery of health care to the entire population,
without discrimination, on the basis of service priorities. Were
institutions or individuals to be denied an opportunity to participate in
the delivery of such services on the basis of their religious
affiliation, such action would surely amount to discrimination by the
State in breach of the Declaration.
"It should be noted that the particular arrangements made with
voluntary hospitals for the provision of service apply to hospitals
associated with the minority denominations on the same basis as those
associated with the religious denomination of the majority."
Italy
49. In a communication of 19 October 1988 addressed to the Government
concerned, the followinq information was transmitted by the Special Rapporteur:
"It has been alleged that the lengthy criminal proceedings initiated
in 1981 against the Milan Association of the Church of Scientology (on
charges includinq criminal association, fraud and the illegal practice of
the medical profession), which are still pending completion, do not allow
for a fair hearing or trial within a reasonable time. It has been
reported that after seven years of investigation, the Milan Examining
Judge conducting the investigation has ordered the closure of all
20 Italian churches and missions of Scientology and the church related
Narconon drug rehabilitation groups. All religious literature has
reportedly been seized. On 28 May 1988, the Examining Judge reportedly
issued an arrest warrant which resulted in the arrest of 28 church
members. As of September 1988, several were reported to be held under
house arrest and five to be still in prison."