E/CN.4/1992/52
page 29
According to the information received, Mr. Mehmet Emin Aga was forcibly
removed from office and expelled from its premises with the help of the
police. He is said to have been ill-treated and to have subsequently suffered
a heart attack. It has been reported that Mr. Mehmet Emin Aga was
hospitalized and had gone on a hunger strike.
According to the sources, some 500 members of the Muslim community staged
a peaceful sit-in demonstration on the morning of 23 August 1991 in protest
against the appointment of the new Mufti and the violent manner in which
Mr. Mehmet Emin Aga had been removed from office. The hundreds of policemen
who are said to have been present reportedly hesitated to intervene and
protect the demonstrators when 40 to 50 persons carrying stones, sticks and
metal bars attacked them and wounded 36 persons. It has also been alleged
that ten shops belonging to members of this community were damaged and that
assaults on mosques were carried out preventing the Muslim community [from
observing] their right to practise their faith."
45. On 30 November 1991, the Permanent Mission of Greece to the
United Nations Office at Geneva transmitted the following communication to
the Special Rapporteur:
"On 22 August 1991, the new Mufti of Xanthi, Mr. Mehmet Emin Sinikoglou,
assumed his duties. Consequently, the interim mission of Mr. Mehmet Emin Aga,
in charge after the death last year of Mufti Aga Mustafa, was terminated.
However, Mr. Aga illegally refused to withdraw from the premises of the Office
of the Mufti. He did so, only when health reasons (high blood pressure
crisis) obliged him to be hospitalized, upon recommendation of medical doctors.
The new Mufti, Mr. Emin Sinikoglou, born in 1939 in the village of
Echinos (Xanthi) had studied for six years in the Islamic religious schools of
Komotini and Recat. He later attended the High Theological School in the
University of Medina, from which he graduated in 1971. Following these
studies, he did post-graduate work at the University of Baghdad.
Mr. Sinikoglou's selection as Mufti was conducted in implementation of
Law 1920/4.2.1991 regarding 'Muslim Religious Ministers'. More specifically,
the enlarged Committee consisting of Greek Muslim religious ministers and
prominent Greek Muslim citizens had to examine the qualifications of the seven
candidates. From among them, and upon the recommendation of the Committee,
the Minister of Education and Religious Affairs finally selected one, namely
Mr. Emin Sinikoglou, on the basis of his qualifications, personal and formal,
to be appointed by presidential decree. The allegations contained in annex I
of your letter, according to which a petition protesting this appointment and
reportedly signed by all the religious leaders of the Muslim minority and
submitted to the Parliament, are totally groundless.
In this connection, it should be stressed that it is obviously with the
participation of the Muslim element, as described above, that the Hellenic
Republic appoints the religious minister of the prefecture, who, apart from
religious jurisdiction, disposes of administrative competence towards the
religious ministers in his region and judicial jurisdiction on issues of
family and inheritance law as well. It is perhaps useful to recall that
Greece is a country accepting the exercise of judicial jurisdiction by a Mufti.