E/CN.4/1992/52
page 87
In view of the fact that the active ingredient of peyote is a
hallucinogenic substance, many States maintain exemptions for the religious
use of peyote which give the indigenous people the 'right to use the plant for
ceremonial purposes'. It has further been alleged that the Congress has
recognized that certain substances, such as peyote, 'have religious
significance because they are sacred, they have power, they heal, they are
necessary to the exercise of the rites of religion, they are necessary to the
cultural integrity of the tribe, and, therefore, religious survival'."
73.
Additional information was sent under annex II as follows:
"According to the sources of information concerning the case of Lvng v.
Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association previously mentioned in
report E/CN.4/1989/44 which the Special Rapporteur submitted to the Commission
on Human Rights at its forty-fifth session, additional clarifications ought to
be made with regard to the case. At the time of the publication of the
aforementioned report, it remained pending before a panel of the United States
Court of Appeals for the ninth circuit.
According to the information received, the case at hand does not concern
only a six-mile paved road on government land linking the California towns of
Gasquet and Orleans but a 1981 proposal of the United States Forest Service to
build 200 miles of logging roads through the Blue Creek Unit where the land is
located and remove about 733 million board feet of timber from the area over
the next 80 years. Blue Creek, a tributary of the Klamath River, is said to
be surrounded by 30,000 hectares of land that make up the Blue Creek Unit,
half of which is still reportedly covered with virgin Douglas fir forests.
According to the sources, Indians Jimmie James, Sam Jones, Lowana Branter
and Christopher Peters together with several environmental organizations took
legal action to block this plan since they thought it would destroy the
sacredness of the area and hinder the practice of traditional religious
ceremonies. In April 1988, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that
the Indian sacred sites in Blue Creek Unit are not legally protected because
the Unit as a whole is the property of the Government.
It has been alleged that the Government can have no claim on this land in
view of the fact that the Klamath and Hoopa Indian tribes never ceded it to
the United States. The treaty concluded on 6 October 1851 was reportedly
never ratified by the United States and the Government is said to never have
performed its obligations pursuant to the treaty while the two tribes were
still removed to small reservations. In addition, these tribes reportedly
never agreed to relinquish their right to continue to use and enjoy sacred
sites located on these lands. The north-eastern corner of the Blue Creek Unit
is reportedly considered to be sacred land by the Yurok, Karok and Tolowa
Indian tribes who use several mountain peaks, including Chimney Rock and
Doctor Rock, as places of worship. The participants in the tribes' three most
important annual ceremonies, such as the White Deerskin Dance, must pray on
these mountain peaks in order to prepare for their religious duties.
According to the sources, the Yurok, Karok and Tolowa Indian tribes did not
participate in nor consent to the 1851 treaty and never gave up their right to
use the land."