E/CN.4/1992/52
page 167
in the past between two religions belonging to Western Christianity. At the
time, religious orders whose religious activities were perceived as dangerous
for the State or as disturbing the peace among different creeds were banned,
as was the establishment of new convents or religious orders. When no clashes
were reported for a very long time, the articles on religious denominations
were repealed.
143. In its reply, the Government of Australia indicated that incidents of
religious violence had occurred because persons practising certain religions
had been victims of discrimination or violence on the basis of an imputed
link with a particular ethnic background. The Government has established
arrangements to investigate and deal with such incidents which include
consultation with the leaders of communities that may be the victims of
violence. The Government of Egypt stated that there have been "a few
limited attempts to exploit criminal incidents with a view to giving them
a confessional dimension".
144. Clashes between religious denominations have also occurred when these
denominations have been banned for protracted periods. The Governments of
Romania and the Ukrainian SSR have indicated that interdenominational conflict
has involved property and status disputes between the Uniate (Greek Catholic)
and the Orthodox Churches. Although the Romanian Uniate Church has recently
been legalized, the Government indicated that the conflict concerning the
return of its property has not yet been solved in a satisfactory manner.
In the Ukrainian SSR, the revival of the two ancient branches of the
Ukrainian Church, the Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church, which was
banned in 1928, and the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church, which was banned
in 1946, has reportedly not only led to disputes with regard to church
property but has given rise to very serious interdenominational conflict
regarding their respective spheres of influence.
145. The Government of Israel indicated in its reply that, in view of
its guardianship of the holy places of important religious communities,
it occupies a particular position and "sees itself entrusted with the heavy
responsibility of protecting religious values, norms and places which are
divinely holy for peoples all over the world". Israel perceives the
"infrequency with which there are clashes between different communities on
the basis of religion as a clear indication of the success of tits] policy
of guaranteeing the rights of the various religious communities ...".
146. The Special Rapporteur has noted that the responses to the questionnaire
provided by the Governments are frequently in contradiction with incidents of
religious intolerance which have been reported to him. For example, attention
has been drawn to incidents involving strife between Christian and Muslim
religious communities which are said to have occurred in the Union of Soviet
Socialist Republics. Serious incidents involving Christians and Muslims have
allegedly occurred in Egypt and resulted in the death of a number of persons.
Clashes between the Muslim and Hindu communities have reportedly occurred in
India, while incidents involving members of different communities which both
consider themselves Muslims have taken place in Pakistan. Incidents are
also reported to have occurred between two Christian denominations in
Northern Ireland.