A/HRC/24/41/Add.3
27.
In many parts of the region, indicators for access to education are significantly
worse in areas with high concentrations of indigenous peoples, and illiteracy rates in those
areas are high. The lack of education in indigenous languages, culturally inappropriate
curricula, distance of schools from indigenous communities, and inadequate
accommodation contribute to low levels of educational achievement and high dropout rates
among indigenous peoples. While mother tongue education is provided in some places, the
Special Rapporteur was informed that such programmes, overall, are lacking.
28.
Reports received during the consultation also allege that indicators for health are
worse in areas where indigenous peoples are living. Food insecurity, chronic hunger and
malnutrition are serious issues facing the region’s indigenous peoples, with obvious
impacts on health. These conditions are attributable in large part to indigenous peoples’ loss
of lands, which has had a profoundly negative impact on their self-sustained means of
subsistence. Traditional subsistence activities, including yak-raising, fishing, rice farming,
and forest gathering, are also threatened by a range of infrastructure, development agroindustrial, and conservation projects. There are also allegations of widespread health
impacts of extractive projects.
29.
A related issue of concern is the lack of birth registration or citizenship
documentation afforded to indigenous individuals in some countries, for varying reasons,
which limits many indigenous peoples’ access to basic public services including for health
and education. This situation reportedly contributes to an increased vulnerability of women
and children to trafficking. Participants noted that some progress has been made in
remedying this situation, although much more remains to be done. Furthermore, in some
areas, indigenous groups are currently internally displaced as a result of armed conflict, and
they suffer extreme social and economic hardship.
30.
In some countries in the Asia region, resettlement programmes have been framed as
developmental in nature, including programmes to cluster scattered indigenous
communities in lowland villages in order to provide them with improved access to public
services and infrastructure. However, indigenous organizations point to deterioration in
indicators related to poverty, malnutrition, health and mortality in cases where communities
have been relocated.
b.
Recognition
31.
As discussed earlier, a number of Asian Governments have yet to accept the
applicability of the concept of “indigenous peoples” to those groups in their countries that
share characteristics similar to those of indigenous peoples in other regions of the world. In
this regard, the notion that the entire population of the country is indigenous has been used
as a justification for denying recognition of particular indigenous peoples as such. In regard
to those countries in which some form of recognition is provided, participants in the
consultation complained that the procedures through which recognition is afforded
constitute limitations on indigenous peoples’ right to self-determination and opportunities
for self-identification and definition. Further, procedural requirements in some countries to
register as legal entities in order to obtain titles over lands, or to participate in government
processes, was cited as a matter of concern in some countries.
32.
According to the information received by the Special Rapporteur during the
consultation, notions of “economic backwardness” and “primitiveness” continue to
underpin the definition of groups in some countries. Further, discriminatory perspectives
that indigenous peoples should be assimilated into mainstream society in order to address
their “backwardness” are still reflected in the development polices of a number of
countries. Another related concern among indigenous peoples in the region is in the
perception of a significant divergence between official and actual population figures, which
10