A/HRC/7/23/Add.2
page 11
Council and Mission established by the Ministry of Culture in 1980 have been tasked with
preserving key constituents of the identity of local cultures and helping to coordinate
ethnological research policy throughout metropolitan France and its overseas departments,
regions and communities”.
26. The independent expert considers such issues to be central to the 1992 Declaration on the
Rights of Minorities. Even when linguistic minorities are relatively well integrated in economic,
social and political fields, the 1992 Declaration8 places great emphasis on preservation of
linguistic, religious and cultural identity. The State is under a positive obligation to “create
favourable conditions” in this regard. Information received suggests that policy and practice in
France require review in consultation with the affected communities themselves, with a view to
achieving consistency of approach and policy.
C. Rights of religious minorities
27. France maintains the principles of secularism (laïcité) in regard to different religious faiths.
Those of Muslim faith, however, may face particular challenges. Under conditions of societal
intolerance, suspicion, misunderstanding of Islam and growing Islamophobia, the principle of
non-discrimination alone is not sufficient to ensure equality in practice. Concerns were raised
with the independent expert regarding provision of Muslim prayer facilities and mosques. There
is no specific law on the construction of places of worship. While the same rules apply to all
religious communities with respect to leases, land use and ownership and building restrictions,
community prejudices may result in unequal treatment by local authorities, leading to undue
restrictions on Muslim communities. There is a perception of bias when in practice these laws
are only relevant to the building of mosques because in secular France, Islam is the primary
religion with a growing need for places of worship.
28. Estimates put the Muslim population in France at 5 to 6 million people, the largest in
Western Europe, most of whom are part of settled and established communities. The independent
expert welcomes the positive practice of government recognition of different religious
communities and initiatives, including the establishment of the French Council of the Muslim
Faith, that play an important role in a process of interfaith and inter-community dialogue.
29. The innovative “Marseilles Hope” initiative supported by town hall and municipal
authorities is a collective of religious leaders who meet together and with local authorities to
share information, views and issues, and to maintain positive and constructive communication.
Founded in 1989 as a response to growing urban violence, the body promotes inter-community
understanding and “social peace” through a range of activities including interfaith symposiums.
Marseilles Hope was consistently highlighted by all respondents as an exemplary initiative of
interfaith and community dialogue.
8
Article 1 states that “States shall protect the existence and the national or ethnic, cultural,
religious and linguistic identity of minorities within their respective territories and shall
encourage conditions for the promotion of that identity” and that “States shall adopt appropriate
legislative and other measures to achieve those ends”.