E/CN.4/2003/24
page 42
motivated the only indication that this might be the case is a production order served
at HM Prison Altcourse in November 1999 where it recorded that Robert Stewart was
a suspect in an allegation of racially motivated malicious communication and
harassment. There was no mention of any racial motivation on the subsequent court
warrants;
•
No other evidence that Robert Stewart exhibited racist behaviour towards prisoners
or staff during his time at Feltham was found. He shared a double cell with
Zahid Mubarek from 8 February onwards with no apparent problems until the tragic
event of 21 March. During this time, Zahid made no complaints against his cellmate
nor did he request to move cells.
Present status of any uncompleted investigation
81.
The Director-General of the Prison Service, Martin Narey, also asked the Commission
for Racial Equality in November 2000 to consider the circumstances leading to this death as part
of its wider-ranging investigation into racism in the Prison Service. This investigation is now
nearing completion.
Compensation
82.
Compensation of £20,000 was offered to the family of Zahid Mubarek in
September 2001. They have not yet responded formally to this offer.
Any other information/observations
83.
The investigation highlighted a number of areas at the prison where improvements were
necessary. In all, it made 26 recommendations addressing areas such as screening on reception,
and the availability and scrutiny of medical records; protection from harassment procedures;
policy and procedures for reading and stopping mail; the availability of security information files
from previous establishments; security, reception and Duty Governor training; and the searching
strategy. Of these 26 recommendations, all but one have been implemented in full. The
outstanding recommendation concerned the provision of a single “stopped letter” register to each
wing. This was felt to be unworkable and a single register had been provided for the entire
establishment.
84.
The part of the investigation on racist behaviour led to the conclusion that Feltham was
institutionally racist. This conclusion was based on the fact that there was clear evidence of a
lack of understanding of racism and race relations amongst staff as well as including the
suggestion that a minority of staff did behave in a racist manner to their colleagues and to
prisoners.
85.
It should be noted that, following her inspection of Feltham in January 2002, the outcome
of which was published on 15 October 2002, Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Prisons was very
positive about improvements at Feltham in general, and about race relations in particular. She