E/CN.4/2002/94/Add.1
page 13
32.
A matter of grave concern is the information received by the Special Rapporteur
concerning the situation of women migrants and minors who are sexually abused by smugglers
as part of the price they have to pay. The need to leave the country exposes the women to harsh
forms of abuse by these networks and by the security or migration officials in the countries of
transit and destination.
33.
The migrants’ families also described the oppression they experience vis-à-vis the
usurers, who collect between 6 and 8 per cent interest each month, and the existence of a
network of lawyers linked with the networks of smugglers, who pressure the migrants to pay by
threatening to seize land, houses and property. In the face of this phenomenon, it is important to
emphasize the difficulties reported by Ecuadorians in obtaining credit through official channels.
In this context it will be important for the Government to fulfil the commitment it entered into in
the initial agreements concluded as part of the dialogue on migration between the Government
and indigenous, peasant and social organizations relating to the establishment of a fund under the
programme for the development of Ecuadorian migrants and their families. Against the
background of these problems, the Special Rapporteur received accounts from young people who
have debts ranging from US$ 18,000 to US$ 40,000 and who find themselves in a vicious and
perverse circle of dependence on the smugglers. The smugglers promise to make three attempts
at entering the target country when they conclude a deal with migrants. When the first attempt
fails, the only way the young people and migrants in general have of paying their debt is to try
again, so that they are wholly dependent on the smuggler to pay what they owe. The “three
attempts” promise also affects the ability of migrants to denounce networks of smugglers and
usurers.
34.
The Special Rapporteur noted that remittances are not used for activities that are
productive or generate jobs, but rather for superfluous expenditure, which facilitates drug
addiction among young people and, as a result, the abandonment of studies. In this regard the
Special Rapporteur was most interested in information supplied by Netherlands aid officials
concerning income-generating programmes being implemented in areas affected by high levels
of migration, as well as other initiatives by bodies such as CONAMU and UNDP. IOM
informed the Special Rapporteur of the ways in which it is advising the Government on the
implementation of programmes which could be of benefit to migrants’ relatives who remain
behind.
35.
A serious problem which stood out during the Special Rapporteur’s visit is the impunity
enjoyed by the networks of migrant-smugglers. The Governor of Azuay said that his office is
working with the civil registration authorities to ensure better monitoring of the issue of
documents. The Special Rapporteur was informed that many people make use of agents to
handle their papers and do not become involved in procedures personally. The Governor also
said that meetings had been held with the association of travel agents to alert them to the
problem of smuggling and encourage them to gain thorough knowledge of their clients. The
acting prefect of El Cañar said that the police were aware of, and had lists of the names of, some
30-40 highly influential people in the area who are involved in smuggling migrants. In the office
of the Governor of Guayas, the deputy chief of migration for the coastal area explained the role
of the police in preventing and suppressing the phenomenon of illegal migration and smuggling,
as well as the lack of personnel and logistical facilities to tackle the problem. As an example, it
was reported that in the province of Manabi, where various smuggling networks are active, there