E/CN.4/2004/80/Add.2
page 14
D. The conflict in Chiapas
38.
As a result of the EZLN uprising in 1994 the collective and individual human rights of
indigenous people in many communities were violated. The failure to meet indigenous demands
has also caused strains between various social and political organizations in the region that
have led to extreme violence and serious human rights violations in which some government
authorities are not blameless. As in other such conflicts, this has polarized the ideological and
political positions of the contending parties, NGOs and public opinion in general.
39.
The 1995 negotiations did not culminate in a peace agreement and provide a solution to
the Zapatista proposals; latent conflict continues, making the protection of human rights in the
area a highly precarious business. The current Coordinator for Dialogue and Negotiation in
Chiapas has been unable to re-establish contact with EZLN despite the action undertaken,
according to the Government, to resume dialogue, and he has concentrated on promoting
development in indigenous communities. There are, however, two issues of special concern to
the Special Rapporteur: displaced persons and reports of paramilitary activity and an excessive
military presence.
Internally displaced persons
40.
More than 12,000 persons have been displaced by the conflict. Some received aid from
the Government or from national and international humanitarian organizations. Generally
speaking, their conditions of existence are extremely difficult. As a result of negotiations
between the Government and the Displaced Persons’ Commission, a start was made on the return
or resettlement of some hundreds of families who receive material support and whose security it
has been endeavoured to protect by means of reconciliation agreements between opposing
groups. Pursuant to the recommendations made by the Representative of the Secretary-General
on internally displaced persons in 2002, the Government has set up an inter-ministerial
Commission and has taken some action, though it admits that the financial resources
available to it are limited. This effort came late and to date has been inadequate. Fear and
insecurity continue to exist among the displaced, and halfway through 2003 the problem is
still extant.
41.
In other indigenous regions of Mexico there are also displaced persons who are never
mentioned. These are people who were relocated without their consent to build a dam or
some other project many years ago and are still waiting for the compensation the Government
offered them.
The paramilitary and militarization
42.
The violence amidst which the indigenous communities of Chiapas live is partly the
aftermath of action in the 1990s by paramilitary groups linked to local and State authorities
which played a violent role in the region’s political and social conflicts with their toll of murders,
injuries, disappearances and displacements. Although they have kept a lower profile under the
present administration, it is reported that they have not been disbanded or disarmed.