E/CN.4/1999/58/Add.2
page 15
55.
According to the representative in Ho Chi Minh City, the teaching of
Buddhism was independent, whereas the list of candidate students had to be
submitted to the authorities, which always gave their approval. In reply to
the question by the Special Rapporteur concerning the presence of false bonzes
in the pagodas, it was stated to be an epiphenomenon.
56.
The representatives in Hue and Ho Chi Minh City said that Buddhism could
contribute to the development of Viet Nam and, reciprocally, achieve its own
development. They hoped that financial circumstances would improve to enable
Buddhism to make progress through places of worship and training institutes.
57.
On the subject of the EBUV, the representatives of the Buddhist
Association of Viet Nam explained that the leaders of that organization had
refused to become united within the Association because of their own
understanding of the development of Buddhism and of State-controlled
institutions.
58.
Representatives in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City stated that the arrests of
the EBUV leaders were more particularly linked to their non-acceptance of the
Buddhist Association of Viet Nam and of the political regime, as well as their
activities outside the sole recognized Buddhist association.
59.
One representative said that the leaders of the Buddhist Association of
Viet Nam could, on the one hand, ask the Government to amnesty the arrested
monks and, on the other, approach the authorities in cases of arbitrary
arrest. A representative in Hue said that the Buddhist Association of
Viet Nam had no views on these arrests and sentences, which were a matter for
the State.
60.
One representative in Hue explained that many EBUV members had rejoined
the Buddhist Association of Viet Nam and that, however strong it might have
been in the past, the EBUV no longer represented more than a minority of
Buddhists. He added that the EBUV nevertheless still claimed to represent the
majority and accused the Buddhist Association of Viet Nam of being a
State-controlled organization. In connection with the Special Rapporteur's
information concerning the demonstration by 40,000 bonzes in Hue on
24 March 1993 and the arrests of Thich Khong Than, Thich Nhat Ban and
Thich Hai Chanh, the representative in Hue queried the number of
demonstrators, the figure of 40,000 bonzes being an unrealistic one, in
comparison with a population of Hue estimated at 100,000, and one which must
have included passers-by. He added that the demonstration had been the act of
young bonzes who had caused some disorder in respect of the Buddhist
Association of Viet Nam and emphasized that the cases of imprisonment were
based on charges of breaches of the peace.
61.
On the subject of the Khmers Krom and the allegation of their
marginalization, including religious marginalization, the representative of
the Buddhist Association of Viet Nam in Hanoi said that, while minor problems
existed, their situation was generally satisfactory. It was stated that the
Buddhist Association of Viet Nam was supporting the Khmers Krom, particularly
by sending bonzes on study courses abroad. The representative at Hue said
that the Khmers Krom were represented on the Central Committee of the Buddhist
Association of Viet Nam.