A/HRC/53/26
Roraima State after an increased inflow of Venezuelans. There was also growth in retail trade
and exports, with a 25 per cent increase in the amount of state tax collected on the circulation
of goods and services between the end of 2018 and the first semester of 2019. 43
58.
Migrant workers also generate revenue for their countries of origin, which is
undeniably beneficial. In India, migrant workers sent home between $90 and $100 billion in
remittances in 2022 alone. In the Philippines, in 2021, remittances from migrant workers
increased by 3.6 per cent to an all-time high of $36.14 billion. With reference to cultural
contributions, the presence of migrant communities in their countries of destination may also
help to bridge cultural gaps by promoting diversity and introducing new cultures and
perspectives through various activities, including sports, community outreach and the
observance of holidays. The cultural diversity owed to migratory movements allows for the
sharing of new perspectives and life experiences through cross-cultural interactions, the
emergence of innovative and hybrid cultural practices and a general societal openness to
difference and change.44
59.
In countries of destination, labour migration may also generate additional employment
opportunities, rejuvenate the workforce, contribute to social protection schemes and provide
such beneficial feedback effects as knowledge, skills and technology transfer. Well-governed
labour migration also raises living standards and may be an important source of
empowerment for migrant workers. Furthermore, women’s participation in the labour force
is a driver of growth and poverty reduction, and leveraging women’s skills is essential for
societies to prosper. For many women, labour migration is a positive experience, providing
opportunities to strengthen livelihoods and autonomy. Evidence is mounting that gender
equality in labour migration is smart economics.
60.
While the Special Rapporteur takes note of the important above-mentioned
information and data with respect to the contribution of migrants to the economy of
destination countries and communities, he would like to emphasize the need to rethink and
change the way migration is spoken about, especially when harmful narratives on migration
are inserted into the public discourse. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur takes the
opportunity to observe that well-meaning narratives promote the positive economic
contributions migrants make to their countries of origin and destination, emphasizing the
economic benefits of migration. However, it should be noted that such messaging does not
tend to resonate with audiences. It also risks reinforcing the perception of migrants as a
commodity or instrumentalizing them as exploitable units of labour to fulfil labour market
needs. Such messaging may also invoke a negative framing, in which migrants are seen as a
threat to jobs, employment standards and union power or to the welfare system. It may also
jeopardize the recognition of migrants as rights holders who are entitled to decent work,
social protection and benefits, regardless of their contributions. The Special Rapporteur
would like to highlight the need to focus on a positive narrative in which social and cultural
abundance is valued and respect for people’s rights is seen as improving everyone’s situation
– when “we work together, we can achieve shared goals and improve our communities”.
Centralizing non-economic values is key for societies to prosper, including such values as
kindness, caring for each other and solidarity.45
2.
Moving forward on regularization under international human rights law
61.
While the Special Rapporteur takes note of some progress on the implementation of
regularization, it is nonetheless important to refer to the challenges faced in designing and
implementing regularization processes. In some countries, many people seeking asylum are
considered in the same way as undocumented migrants or are granted a very precarious
temporary status that does not provide adequate protection because of the lack of a legal
framework and/or the implementation of a framework to protect refugees and others in need
of international protection. Such lack of protection of refugees and asylum-seekers increases
their risk of statelessness. Children born to undocumented refugees and asylum-seekers and
43
44
45
14
See submission from Conectas Brazil.
See submission from the Migrant Forum in Asia.
See OHCHR, “Step 7: do no harm – be aware of unconscious bias in messaging, and avoid
discrimination” (2020).
GE.23-06641