A/HRC/28/57/Add.1
involved. It is important to hear and acknowledge the narratives of all sides of a conflict in
order to better promote mutual understanding, and thereby reconciliation, and also to enable
contemporary challenges of exclusion and violence to be addressed.
27.
In her discussions with officials, the Special Rapporteur noted that the objectives of
history teaching, especially in secondary schools, were several and seemingly of equal
importance: learning about and understanding events that took place in the past; preserving
the traditions, moral values and cultural identity of the Vietnamese people; preserving Viet
Nam as a nation; and promoting patriotism. For example, family traditions are integrated in
history teaching with a view to minimizing the divorce rate and fostering care for family
elders. Connections between pupils/students and the military are promoted through, for
example, exchanges with military schools and activities for students to engage with military
officers and cadets (trainees). In that regard, the Special Rapporteur draws the attention of
the Vietnamese authorities to her recommendation (A/68/296, para. 88 (a)) that history
teaching should not serve the purpose of strengthening patriotism, fortifying national
identity or shaping the young in line with the official ideology. Such purposes are not in
keeping with history being taught as an academic discipline.
28.
History teachers in Viet Nam do try to find new ways of teaching history so as to
make it more interesting and relevant for students, focusing less on remembering dates and
offering greater possibilities to access reliable additional information. Efforts are under way
to foster the use of cultural heritage as a resource in education and training, including by
means of visits to historical sites, thanks to a 2013 agreement between the Ministry of
Culture and the Ministry of Education. Teachers are encouraged to use the Internet to
access additional materials and to motivate students to find supplementary information
through library reference books and online research. The Special Rapporteur welcomes
those steps and encourages the Government to increase its efforts in that direction.
29.
As teachers are expected to guide students regarding where to find reliable
additional information, a crucial question is whether teachers themselves have access to a
sufficiently wide array of such information, and how do they help students to distinguish
between what is reliable and what is not.
30.
In Ho Chi Minh City, the Special Rapporteur was informed that history teachers
were expected to keep themselves up to date. School teachers meet on a monthly basis and
report narratives that conflict with what is considered to be the historical truth to the City
History Council under the City Department of Education and Training. The Department,
which is composed of former and experienced history teachers with close relationships with
academia, ensures the harmonization of history teaching in all schools. Although there are
debates amongst teachers on historical narratives, teachers follow the official curricula and
use official government-recognized historical sources.
31.
The participation of teachers in the elaboration and development of the history
programme and lessons seems limited, but the Government has launched a programme for
teachers to post their history lessons on the Internet. Delegations from the Ministry of
Education go to schools to gather teachers’ feedback on textbooks. Some teachers indicated
that they could report flaws in official textbooks and share their assessment of the online
library provided by the Ministry of Education. Discussions with teachers do not seem to
indicate, however, that this is well implemented in practice.
32.
The school curriculum requires that a certain amount of time be devoted to local
history. While this is important, it does not guarantee the introduction of a multiperspective
approach. Some interlocutors complained that history teaching focused on the history of the
Kinh majority and disregarded the history and cultural heritage of groups and minorities
such as the Cham, the Khmer people of the Mekong Delta (who also sometimes selfidentify as Khmer Krom) and groups in the Central Highlights, commonly referred to as
8