A/HRC/35/25/Add.2
3.
Protective custody
99.
Due to a shortage of suitable accommodation or of a comprehensive protection
system for child asylum seekers and migrants, children are often detained in “protective
custody”, in reception and identification centres, or in police stations or pre-removal centres
under police custody, while awaiting referral to an adequate shelter facility, which often
takes longer than the 45 days prescribed by law.
100. The number of shelter places available for unaccompanied minors is drastically
below needs. The Special Rapporteur was informed that there were 347 shelter spaces for
unaccompanied minors as of 8 March 2016, and 119 unaccompanied minors were waiting
to be placed in a shelter. By mid-February 2017, the number of unaccompanied minors was
2,100, while the available shelters could only accommodate 1,310.19
101. The Special Rapporteur met with unaccompanied minors, detained in a separate
section in the Moria Reception and Identification Centre and welcomes the information that
many were transferred to shelters between his visit and March 2017. Some of them were
seriously traumatized and reported bullying and incidents of violence, without protection
from the supervising authorities. On the mainland, the Special Rapporteur met
unaccompanied minors locked in police station cells 24/7 without access to the outdoors for
over two weeks and without any recreational or educational activity. He was informed that
some may stay for a month or more.
102. Children in “protective custody” lack access to interpreters, to legal assistance, and
to information presented in a child-friendly manner, and hence are not aware of their reason
for detention, of the next steps in the process and of their rights. Most of them face serious
mental health issues, with a particularly high number of suicide attempts. Psychological
services are often not available, although some local NGOs provide such services.
103. Overall, as determined by the Committee on the Rights of the Child, administrative
detention based on the immigration status of the child or of his or her parents can never be
in the best interest of a child. Given the incalculable detrimental effects that detention has
on children’s mental and physical health and development, it is utterly unacceptable for
children to be detained simply because of an administrative status.
104. Regardless of the conditions in which children are held, detention has a profound
and negative impact on child health and development. Even short periods of detention can
undermine a child’s psychological and physical well-being and compromise cognitive
development. The threshold at which treatment or punishment may be classified as cruel,
inhuman or degrading is therefore lower in the case of children, and in particular in the case
of children deprived of their liberty.
VII. Role of the European Union
105. While responding to the urgent needs of migrants within Greece, the country is
simultaneously under pressure to implement austerity measures, which have severe
consequences on the Greek people. It is therefore critical that the responsibility be shared,
that international obligations be upheld, and that the human rights of all be protected.
106. The “migration crisis” is not simply a political problem: the full measure of the
constitutional, European and international frameworks applies. Although the European
Union adopted two decisions in 2015 to relocate at least 66,400 persons from Greece, the
Special Rapporteur notes that relocation remains a big challenge. As at 27 February 2017,
only 9,610 transfers had taken place.20 Unfortunately, the behaviour of many actors in the
European Union, and especially in European Union Member States, seems to indicate that
they consider human rights and the rule of law to be dispensable in regard to migrants
under these circumstances. The Special Rapporteur urges the European Union to urgently
19
20
16
See https://data2.unhcr.org/en/documents/download/53990.
See https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/sites/homeaffairs/files/what-we-do/policies/europeanagenda-migration/20170302_tenth_report_on_relocation_and_resettlement_annex_1_en.pdf.