E/CN.4/1998/6/Add.1
page 15
(b)
Other areas
66.
In recent years, there has been a large increase in the number of
Buddhists and Hindus in Australia and their communities are now being
structured. As indicated above, their integration into Australian society has
been facilitated by the authorities, which are also helping to maintain their
cultural and religious identity in accordance with their policy of cultural,
ethnic and religious diversity. The situation of these minorities in
religious and non-religious matters seems to be satisfactory, despite a few
isolated incidents attributable not to religious intolerance, but, rather, to
ignorance fuelling manifestations of racism encouraged by some isolated
extremist political statements, such as those by MP Pauline Hanson.
4.
(a)
Other communities
Church of Scientology
67.
By virtue of the 1983 High Court decision in Church of the New Faith v.
Commission for Pay-Roll Tax, the Church of Scientology is recognized as a
religious institution in Australia and is therefore entitled to tax relief
(see above, para. 11). Several religious and non-governmental commentators
expressed the view that it was really a sect based on a combination of
elements borrowed from psychology and religion and on a search for profit at
the expense of its members, achieved through brainwashing, chiefly among young
people. Scientology awoke not only suspicions, but also fears owing to its
aggressiveness and virulence, especially in its legal proceedings against any
opponent.
68.
Other non-official commentators criticized the pressures exerted by the
Church of Scientology on its members to extract money from them, but they said
that they were not opposed to the community as such.
69.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs said that the Church of Scientology
represented only a small number of individuals in Australia, where people were
free to do what they wanted within the law of the country. He added that new
religious movements sprang up and vanished “like mushrooms” in Australia and
that they did not constitute a problem. The Minister recalled the basic
principle of Australian society, which was religious freedom for any
denomination without the State deciding whether a belief was good or bad, in
order to avoid causing social divisions. Undoubtedly any violations committed
by a religious group should be sanctioned, but they should not lead to banning
the religion as such.
70.
Representatives of the Church of Scientology reported that they enjoyed
total religious freedom, including for their places of worship, and
entertained good relations with the authorities. A few minor problems were
mentioned by those representatives, such as the fact that some religious
groups spread negative propaganda against all new religious movements.
Generally speaking, however, according to the Scientologists, their church
maintained “cordial” relations with the representatives of major religions,