A/80/496
racist hate speech, legitimizing its broad spread. The submissions also contained
descriptions of how such manifestations of racist hate speech could be linked to the
dissemination of misinformation and disinformation and how, in today’s interconnected
world, digital technologies and social media platforms could play a powerful role in
spreading and amplifying racist hate speech. This online amplification of racist hatred
speech can have an impact on the trajectory of conflict within directly affected
countries and spread hatred globally and incite tension and social violence towards
members of racial and ethnic groups that are perceived as being connected to conflicts
in other countries. 18
15. The effect of racist hate speech on the development, outbreak and escalation of
conflict situations has been recognized by multiple human rights entities. It was
acknowledged in the 2013 Rabat Plan of Action on the prohibition of advocacy of
national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination,
hostility or violence that many of the conflicts worldwide had involved a component
of incitement to national, racial or religious hatred. The Committee on the Elimination
of Racial Discrimination’s general recommendation No. 35 (2013), on combating
racist hate speech, underlined the “role of racist hate speech in processes leading to
mass violations of human rights and genocide, and in conflict situations ”. 19 The
Special Rapporteur on minority issues also recognized the relationship between hate
speech and hate crimes, as well as atrocities, including genocide. 20
16. The Special Rapporteur presented a report to the General Assembly in 2023 that
discussed online racist hate speech. 21 In the report, the Special Rapporteur recognized
the link between the most serious forms of hate speech and incitement to
discrimination, hostility and violence and conflict situations. She called upon States
to prohibit and, in the most serious cases, criminalize racist hate speech. The Special
Rapporteur also urged the implementation of initiatives focused on non-legal measures,
such as counter-speech, public awareness campaigns, education, community projects
and steps to build societal support for plurality, based on research and data on the
societal drivers of racist hate speech.
Digital technology in conflict and algorithmic bias
17. Digital technology, in particular artificial intelligence, is playing an increasing
and divisive role in conflict. The development and deployment of artificial
intelligence is interconnected with racist hate speech, as described above. Content shaping algorithms developed by social media companies can play a powerful role in
the spread of racist hate speech that takes place online. Content -shaping algorithms
are designed to maximize the time that people spend on social media platforms and
are exposed to profit-generating advertising. They therefore often prioritize the
dissemination of materials that generate high engagement, regardless of their
credibility, veracity and potential to cause harm. Content-shaping algorithms can lead
to the quick dissemination and amplification of racially hateful materials to a wide
audience, perpetuating harmful beliefs and narratives. 22 An emblematic case of online
racist hate speech fuelling systemic violence was the sustained demonization of the
Rohingya ethnic group in Myanmar on Facebook. This sustained online racist hate
speech, amounting to discrimination, hostility and violence, t ook place ahead of and
__________________
18
19
20
21
22
25-16958
Submissions from Azerbaijan, 4Métrica, HRER, Centre for Truth and Justice, For Progress of
Karabakh, FDI, HRLN, Franciscans International, Lithuania, the State of Palestine, Civil Rights
Defenders, World Jewish Congress, and Atina Solutions.
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, general recommendations No. 35
(2013), para. 3.
See A/HRC/49/46, para. 33.
See A/78/538.
Submission from Pixology Foundation.
7/21