A/53/279
as was confirmed during the course of the mission during
visits to schools, in discussions with pupils and teachers and
by the perusal of textbooks. However, this approach must be
adopted throughout the country to cover India’s entire private
and public school system in order to develop the awareness
of the masses. It is of vital importance that human rights and
tolerance should become the concern of all and not remain the
exclusive preserve of the élite”, the Special Rapporteur would
appreciate if you could indicate your comments as well as
measures undertaken and/or envisaged by your Government.
Comments and measures
As observed by the Special Rapporteur, the broadbasing of the teaching of tolerance, specially in a country with
a high rate of illiteracy, is of vital importance. The teaching
of tolerance has to start with universal education and what is
taught in schools has to be supplemented by the family, social
and religious organizations and the media. Modern as well as
traditional media of mass communication are also being used
for the promotion of national integration. Campaign
programmes for adult literacy have a built-in component of
this nature. These activities would receive a further impetus
from the National Action Plan, currently under elaboration,
to realize the goals of the United Nations Decade on Human
Rights Education. Commemorative activities being planned
for the fiftieth anniversary of the Universal Declaration on
Human Rights also have a strong promotional/human rights
education focus. The above approaches will build on the
strengths of Indian society and avoid the impression of being
“top-down” or pedagogical.
Recommendations
Taking into account paragraph 97 of the report, “The
Special Rapporteur also recommends that the Centre for
Human Rights should provide advisory services on the
organization at the federal and State level of training courses
for teachers in preschool, primary or basic and secondary
educational establishments to make them aware of the
importance of teaching the principles of tolerance and nondiscrimination based on religion and belief”, the Special
Rapporteur would appreciate if you could indicate your
comments as well as measures undertaken and/or envisaged
by your Government.
Comments and measures
The various programmes described in the preceding
paragraphs indicate the high level of importance given to the
teaching of tolerance in India through human rights education.
Further, through its resolution on tolerance and pluralism at
20
the Commission on Human Rights, India has also been
encouraging the Office of the High Commissioner for Human
Rights to develop expertise in propagating these values
through its own programmes. We would be happy to see the
results of such work carried out by the Office of the High
Commissioner for Human Rights, including in the area of best
practices for the promotion of tolerance.
Recommendations
Taking into account paragraph 98 of the report, “As
regards Jammu and Kashmir and Punjab, the Special
Rapporteur urges all the parties concerned – official and nonofficial, national and foreign – to act calmly and refrain from
exacerbating religious problems to ensure that immutable
religious principles are not affected by political
considerations at the expense of the religious rights of the
communities and, more generally, of tolerance and nondiscrimination based on religion or belief”, the Special
Rapporteur would appreciate if you could indicate your
comments as well as measures undertaken and/or envisaged
by your Government.
Comments and measures
We agree with the Special Rapporteur that religion
should not be exploited to further a political programme,
either national or international. The maintenance of religious
tolerance or the protection of human rights in general has
been affected adversely in certain areas by the activities of
non-State actors. While dealing firmly with violent
extremism, India will strive to ensure that this has no impact
on tolerance, religious rights of minorities and nondiscrimination based on religion and belief. In this task, it
takes comfort from the innate respect for diversity in the
Indian ethos. It is significant to note that despite a clear plan
to widen the communal divide through terrorist attacks,
communal violence never became a problem in either Punjab
or Jammu and Kashmir.