A/65/295
international legal framework, in particular, in that provided by the International
Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
19. In conclusion, the Special Rapporteur affirmed that advocacy of racial or
religious hatred is an external manifestation of something much more profound,
which is intolerance and bigotry. While States have often relied on legislative
responses to the advocacy of racial or religious hatred, the Special Rapporteur
expressed the view that such responses are far from being sufficient to bring about
real changes in mindsets, perceptions and discourse. Indeed, tackling the root causes
of manifestations of religious intolerance affecting an individual’s human rights
requires a much broader set of policy measures, for example, in the areas of
education, awareness-raising and interreligious and intercultural dialogue. The
Special Rapporteur therefore strongly recommended in his report that States put a
strong emphasis on a broad range of preventive measures which aim at fostering a
peaceful society in which, inter alia, freedom of expression and freedom of religion
or belief may be fully exercised by all individuals.
20. On 14 October 2009, the Special Rapporteur participated in an expert seminar
on strengthening cooperation between the European Union and the United Nations
in the struggle against all forms of discrimination, organized by the European Union
and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, in
Brussels. 3 On that occasion, the Special Rapporteur was requested to speak on
intolerance and discrimination against Arabs and Muslims.
21. As a United Nations expert on racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and
related intolerance, the Special Rapporteur recalled that discrimination targeting
Muslims falls within his mandate when linked to discrimination on the ground of
ethnic origin. There is a definite correlation between ethnicity and religious
affiliation. In that regard, he mentioned that the Committee on the Elimination of
Racial Discrimination had also come to that conclusion by referring to the
intersectionality between race and religion. Thus, the Committee addresses issues of
religious discrimination when linked to racial discrimination.
22. In Europe, people of Arab origin are often associated with Islam. The Special
Rapporteur stated that it was therefore often very difficult to address cases of racial
or religious discrimination as they relate to Arabs and Muslims separately. The
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights conclusively documented that
cases of discrimination and violence affecting Arabs and Muslims were complicated
by the fact that they were invariably linked with multiple forms of discrimination
based on ethnic origin, religion and gender. The Special Rapporteur stressed that it
was, therefore, essential to adopt a comprehensive approach towards those acts.
23. While there is evidence that most countries in Europe are aware of the
magnitude of the problem and are committed to addressing it, the Special
Rapporteur emphasized that the intolerance and discrimination experienced by
Muslims and Arabs in the European Union remain a major human rights issue. In
that regard, he strongly deplored acts of violence against individuals on the basis of
their ethnic origin or religious affiliation. He stated that one could not remain silent
when a woman was killed in a court room where she had gone to vindicate her rights
against discrimination as a Muslim, when places of worship or cultural centres were
__________________
3
10-48481
Available from http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/racism/rapporteur/docs/
SpeechBrussels141009.pdf.
7