A/73/178/Rev.1
H.
Migrants with particular protection needs
1.
Migrant children
58. Children and adolescents are one of the weakest links within migratory flows,
especially if they are not accompanied by their parents, relatives or a responsible,
trustworthy adult who protects them from abuse, violence and exploitation and other
risks. If this is compounded by the lack of information that a child or adolescent may
have regarding complaint mechanisms and the institutions to which they can turn in
the event of a violation, if they are unable to read or write, or if they are in a society
that fails to consider their views owing to their young age, the right of access to justice
and the protection thereof by States acquires particular importance.
59. In relation to children and adolescents deprived of their liberty, the Convention
on the Rights of the Child enshrines the right to prompt access to legal and other
appropriate assistance, and the right to a fair trial (art. 37). The Committee on the
Rights of the Child has established that one of the first decisions of the State with
regard to unaccompanied children and children separ ated from their families outside
their country of origin must be the appointment of a guardian or adviser and legal
representative as soon as possible, since this is the most effective mechanism for
protecting the best interests of children and adolescents and ensuring access to
justice. 63 Furthermore, it establishes, as an essential element, “specialized units
within the police, the judiciary, the court system, the prosecutor ’s office, as well as
specialized defenders or other representatives who provide le gal … assistance to the
child”. 64 When it comes to children and adolescents, access to justice must be
understood from the perspective of their best interests, which requires the removal of
obstacles to access to justice, including the lack of affordable an d child-sensitive
complaint mechanisms, technical language, mistrust of adults, and the inability to
read or write. 65
60. The Council of Europe has developed international norms and standards on
migrant children in several instruments, including the 2010 G uidelines of the
Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on child -friendly justice. The
Handbook on European law relating to the rights of the child also points out the need
to adapt justice to children’s needs, especially if they are migrants. In 2017, the
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights compiled Agency guidelines and
opinions, and testimonies of children and adolescents to build and strengthen child friendly justice. In that regard, States must make efforts to learn about the special
needs of children and their perception of justice and the institutional framework.
61. Unaccompanied migrant children face many difficulties in gaining access to
justice, such as a lack of access to guardians and to legal assistance and counselling;
a lack of access to information or procedures for determining the best interests of the
child; and problems with age assessment procedures. The first step towards
implementing laws and policies for the protection of children is their identification as
minors. In spite of established standards on fair and appropriate age assessment
procedures, many States resort to invasive tests (such as medical examinations or
X-rays), the reliability of which is highly questionable. Furthermore, the margin of
error for these tests is barely mentioned in the results, which impedes the application
of the principle of the benefit of the doubt, with many migrant minors being identified
as adults and detained. Moreover, there are no methods for challenging the outcomes
of these proceedings. Belgium, France, Italy, Malta and Sweden are among the few
__________________
63
64
65
18-15902
See general comment No. 6 (2005) on the treatment of unaccompanied a nd separated children
outside their country of origin.
See general comment No. 10 (2007) on children’s rights in juvenile justice, para. 92.
See also A/72/164, A/HRC/29/26, A/HRC/25/35 and A/HRC/16/56.
15/20