However, this does not imply, in any way, a right under international law to exercise
jurisdiction over these persons on the territory of another State without that State’s
consent or to grant citizenship en masse to citizens of another State, including if
this happens as the result of a sum of individual applications.83
At the same time, States cannot “outsource” the protection of minorities residing
on their territory to other States (so-called “kin-States”), as the respect for and
protection of minority rights is primarily the responsibility of the State in which the
minority resides.84
Besides these legal limitations, citizenship policies that have external effects
may create obstacles to friendly, including good neighbourly, relations as well as
additional challenges for the integration of society in the country in which these
minorities reside. Policies that have such negative effects should thus be avoided.
The State of residence holds primary responsibility for the protection of the rights of
its residents, including persons belonging to minorities. This responsibility extends to
residents holding multiple citizenships, and States should not discriminate against dual
citizens. A State can legitimately ask its citizens to rescind other citizenships before
taking up high political positions, such as head of State or member of government.85
37. Multiple citizenships, per se, should not be considered an obstacle to
integration. Granting citizenship by the State of residence to long-term
residents who already hold citizenship of another State may support the
integration process and strengthen links to society. Children who have
acquired more than one citizenship at birth should not be prohibited from
holding multiple citizenships over the course of their lives.
Multiple citizenships reflect the increasing movement of persons across borders as
well as intra-family diversity, including across generations, and growing efforts by
States to retain legal ties with emigrant populations abroad. Providing access to
citizenship to long-term residents while not requiring the renunciation of a previous
citizenship encourages participation and a sense of belonging and may contribute
83
84
85
Bolzano/Bozen Recommendations, especially Recommendations 4, 10 and 11.
Bolzano/Bozen Recommendations, Recommendation 2, and the European Commission for Democracy
Through Law, “Report on the Preferential Treatment of Minorities by their Kin-State” (hereinafter: “Venice
Commission Report”), CDLINF (2001) 19.
Bolzano/Bozen Recommendations, Explanatory Note to Recommendation 11.
44
Guidelines on Integration of Diverse Societies