A/HRC/54/71
Criminal justice system and access to justice
44.
The two main issues regarding racism in the administration and functioning of the
criminal justice system are adherence to the principle of equality before the law and the
criminalization of racism.48 Children and young people of African descent constitute one of
the groups in situations of vulnerability that experience disproportionately low rates of access
to high-quality education and alarmingly high rates of violence, including at the hands of law
enforcement officers. Children and young people of African descent are often seen as adults
and are too often racially profiled and targeted by the police for stop-and-search, fostering
anger, frustration and a lack of faith in law enforcement agencies and, in extreme cases,
provoking suicide.
45.
The difficulties that women experience in gaining access to justice are compounded
by several factors, including societal discrimination, a lack of education and awareness of
their rights and a lack of readily available legal assistance. The situation is even more
troubling for women of African descent, even though relevant international norms exist,
including those reflected in Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination general
recommendations No. 31 (2005) and No. 32 (2009).
46.
The Working Group has expressed concern about the racial profiling and
discrimination faced by people of African descent within the criminal justice system. It has
called for measures to address and prevent racial profiling by law enforcement and to ensure
equal treatment before the law. It has consistently, including in country visit reports, raised
awareness about the overrepresentation of people of African descent in the criminal justice
system and has urged Governments to address the underlying factors contributing to such
overrepresentation, such as socioeconomic inequalities and bias in policing and sentencing.
47.
The Working Group has noted that racial and sexual violence and harassment deprive
women of African descent from accessing justice. The problem is even worse for women of
African descent incarcerated in foreign countries where legal and consular services are
unavailable. It has recommended that legal assistance for women of African descent be
prioritized through awareness-raising, including the development of user-friendly, gendersensitive information guides on the administration of justice.
48.
The Working Group has underlined the importance of questioning the very concept
of justice in all fields and the need to broaden the definition of justice to include social justice,
access to justice and the application of the legal system to address historical injustices.
49.
The Working Group has emphasized the importance of ensuring that people of African
descent have equal access to legal representation and assistance. It has called for measures to
address barriers to legal representation, such as affordability and geographical availability.
50.
The Working Group has condemned the excessive use of force by law enforcement
against people of African descent and has advocated for accountability and justice in cases
of death in State custody. It has also advocated for awareness-raising for law enforcement,
judges and legal professionals to address racial biases and stereotyping and to promote
justice. It has stressed the importance of collecting and analysing disaggregated data to better
understand the experiences of people of African descent in the criminal justice system. Such
data are crucial for evidence-based policymaking and for monitoring progress in addressing
inequalities.
Development
51.
The legacy of colonialism and centuries of enslavement, manifested in contemporary
inequality, structural discrimination and racism against people of African descent, has
impeded the full realization of their right to development. The Working Group recognizes
that historical injustices have undeniably contributed to the poverty, underdevelopment,
marginalization, social exclusion, economic disparities, instability and insecurity that affect
many people in different parts of the world, in particular in developing countries, and also
recognizes the need to develop programmes for the social and economic development of
these societies and of African diaspora communities within the framework of a new
48
GE.23-15301
A/HRC/27/68, para. 19.
11