A/HRC/45/34
murder of “Billy” by the Department of Special Investigation on 23 December 2019. 30
However, on 23 January 2020, the Attorney-General’s Office dropped the murder charges,
citing insufficient evidence, and the outcome of the investigation remains uncertain.
25.
Successive mandate holders have expressed long-standing concerns regarding the
impact of conservation activities on indigenous peoples in Kenya. Since 2017, there has
been an escalation of violence in the Embobut Forest: the Kenya Forest Service has
repeatedly evicted indigenous Sengwer and burned their homes, and arrested community
members. These acts were taking place despite the litigation by the Sengwer challenging
the evictions and the issuance of a court injunction to prevent such evictions in the interim.
Several Sengwer have been shot by the Kenya Forest Service, including one Sengwer
herder who was killed in January 2018. 31 The European Commission supported a climate
change project in the area, which included the Kenya Forest Service among the recipients
of funding. The Special Rapporteur, together with other special procedure mandate holders,
issued a press release in January 2018 calling for the project to ensure respect for human
rights, and within days, the European Commission decided to suspend the project pending
an assessment of its human rights compliance. 32
26.
The Special Rapporteur sent a communication and issued a press release in July
2019 raising concerns over the Supreme Court order to evict up to 9 million Adivasi across
India, as well as over amendments to the Indian Forest Act that would increase the
discretionary policing powers of forest officers. 33 In November 2019, indigenous
representatives and lawyers from India stated that the action by the mandate holder had
undoubtedly increased national debate and had made Adivasi feel supported and that their
voice was legitimized. The eviction order remains suspended. The Supreme Court hearing,
initially scheduled to take place in July 2019, has been postponed until 2020. In addition,
the proposed amendments to the Indian Forest Act were formally withdrawn by the
Government in mid-November 2019 following the intensified national debate. There is
hope that the Supreme Court will give careful consideration to the rights of indigenous
peoples in its final decision on the eviction order. The Special Rapporteur will continue to
monitor the situation closely.
27.
Human rights impacts of business activities, particularly extractive industries, within
or around indigenous peoples’ lands and territories, have also been a continuing concern for
successive mandate holders. The Special Rapporteur and her predecessors have addressed
this topic during their country visits and through thematic reports, communications and
letters, including to business corporations. In February 2019, together with other special
procedure mandate holders, the Special Rapporteur sent a communication to the
Government of the Philippines and to the Australian-based mining company OceanaGold
regarding allegations that the establishment and operation of the gold and copper mine by
OceanaGold Corporation had resulted in violations of the human rights of the indigenous
peoples and local communities living near Didipio, Nueva Vizcaya Province, including
impacts on their livelihoods and overall environmental degradation in the region due to the
project. 34 The company engaged in dialogue with special procedures over human rights
concerns. On 15 October 2019, the company announced publicly that it was suspending its
operation of the Didipio mine. The action of the special procedures may have had a role in
prompting the company to recognize its human rights responsibilities. Disputes have,
however, persisted in 2020, along with allegations that certain activities by the mining
company are still being carried out.
28.
In other cases, courts have taken into account the Special Rapporteur’s country visit
and thematic reports. In regard to Guatemala, some relevant recommendations from the
Guatemala country visit report were considered in the Constitutional Court decision on the
30
31
32
33
34
8
See www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/general/1822474/former-park-chief-charged-on-6-counts-inbilly-murder-case#cxrecs_s.
KEN 1/2018 and OTH 1/2018.
See www.ohchr.org/en/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=22584&LangID=E.
IND 13/2019.
PHL 1/2019 and OTH 2/2019. The company response is available at
https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMResultsBase/DownLoadFile?gId=34621.