A/HRC/51/50
Mi’kmaq are still struggling to realize their treaty rights and suffer from intimidation and
harassment by non-indigenous people when attempting to exercise them.116
D.
Cultural unpreparedness
59.
Implementation is also linked to the need for a cultural framework that favours a
thoroughgoing understanding of the rights of indigenous peoples and the importance of the
commitment made by entering into an agreement. This means creating a shared and stable
environment in which indigenous rights and viewpoints are widely understood so that they
can be fully and consistently implemented.117 Human rights education is a fundamental tool
for reaching this goal, and State officials, in particular, must be trained to comprehend and
apply these rights in performance of their duties. Initiatives such the “treaty education kit”
for school curricula, developed by the Treaty Relations Commission of Manitoba, can
contribute to a common understanding and a culture that respects treaties. 118
VI. Conflict resolution mechanisms
60.
The creation and strengthening of specific mechanisms contribute to the achievement
of respected and enforced treaties, agreements and other constructive arrangements between
indigenous peoples and States. Breaches of agreements create conflicts and may lead to
human rights violations and the breakdown of hard-won partnerships. They must be
appropriately addressed through competent mechanisms to handle and resolve conflict and
redress and remedy grievances. A commitment by States to redress the historical and ongoing
dispossession perpetrated against indigenous peoples is an essential element of a new
relationship with them. These mechanisms should look at past, present and persistent
violations with a human rights-based approach and a thorough comprehension of historical
processes.
61.
The Declaration provides a framework on how to implement processes that can
redress violations of treaties, agreements and other constructive arrangements, as outlined in
studies and reports of the Expert Mechanism 119 and the three United Nations expert
seminars.120 Article 40 of the Declaration sets out the right of indigenous peoples to prompt
decisions through just and fair procedures for the resolution of conflicts and disputes with
States or other parties, as well as to effective remedies for infringements of their individual
and collective rights. Such decisions should give due consideration to international human
rights and the customs, traditions, rules and legal systems of the indigenous peoples
concerned.
62.
Similarly, referring to the recognition and adjudication of the rights of indigenous
peoples to their lands, territories and resources, article 27 Declaration points out the
obligation of States to establish and implement, in conjunction with and with the participation
of indigenous peoples concerned, a fair, independent, impartial, open and transparent process,
giving due recognition to indigenous peoples’ laws, traditions, customs and land tenure
systems.
63.
Article 28 of the Declaration affirms the right of indigenous peoples to seek redress
for violations of their right to land, territories and resources in case of confiscation,
dispossession, occupation, use or damage without their free, prior and informed consent.
Means for redressing such violations can include restitution or, if that is not possible, just,
fair and equitable compensation. Unless otherwise freely agreed upon by the peoples
116
117
118
119
120
14
Sarah Ritchie, “Federal enforcement in N.S. fisheries dispute ‘political’: Mi’kmaw lawyer”, Global
News, 20 September 2021 (available at https://globalnews.ca/news/8204388/liberals-fishery-disputemikmaw-lawyer/).
A/74/149, para. 81 (g).
Submission of the Treaty Relations Commission of Manitoba.
See A/HRC/39/62; A/HRC/45/38; and A/HRC/48/51.
See the compilation of conclusions and recommendations from the United Nations seminars on
treaties, agreements and other constructive arrangements.