A/56/253
45. On 21 May 2001, in Ambon, extremists allegedly attacked Christians causing
the death of at least six people. It is reported that 5,000 people have been killed
since hostilities broke out in the Moluccas in January 1999.
46.
Indonesia replied:
“The Government of Indonesia has repeatedly condemned the violence
associated with the recent Moluccan conflict, which originated in Ambon in
1999 and subsequently spread to most major islands in the chain, resulting in
deaths as well as incalculable damage to infrastructures and public buildings.
In addition, officials estimate that in total over 500,000 persons have been
displaced by the fighting, mainly from the two hardest hit provinces of North
Maluku and Maluku, with approximately 197,000 internally displaced persons
generated from the former and 289,000 displaced persons from the latter.
“With regard to the specific allegations mentioned in the above
communications, President Wahid conceded in late December last year that
hundreds of Christians on the islands of Keswui and Teor had been forced to
convert to Islam in November and December 2000. The President was quick to
express his abhorrence at such acts and condemned the practice outright. As
for the incidences of forced circumcisions and female genital mutilations that
allegedly took place, my Government cannot confirm these reports, although
we concede that acts of gross human rights violations may unfortunately occur
during internecine feuding and in cases of mob attacks. Furthermore, it goes
without saying that the Government of Indonesia strongly deplores any action
that leads to unacceptable physical and psychological trauma. Likewise, my
Government also strongly condemns the 20 May 2001 attacks that occurred in
Soya Kecil, Belakang Soya and Karang Panjang in Ambon, resulting in the
deaths of at least 8 people and the injury of 17 others. The latest reports show
that two members of the heavily armed group of attackers were among those
killed. We deeply regret that these latest skirmishes come at a time when the
rift between the two communities was showing definite signs of healing.
“At this point, we believe that it is necessary to rectify the commonly
held view, as reflected in your communications, that the Moluccan conflict is
driven by religious disparities. More accurately, political and socio-economic
causes, with cultural and ethnic overtones, are at the root of the trouble and
have in turn sparked off religious tensions. Indeed, although the initial fighting
broke out between local residents (Christians) and settlers (Muslims) over land
tenure issues, complicated by status disparities between these two
communities, it only later evolved into what has been perceived as religious
clashes. Moreover, as the conflict gained momentum, ideology or religious
beliefs were superseded by a desire for revenge, with each faction blaming the
other for initiating and perpetuating the violence. As civilians fled to
neighbouring areas, they exported their resentment to their new places of
residence, thereby causing the violence to spread.
“The rapidly spiralling conflict and the sheer numbers of people involved
took the authorities by surprise and initially overwhelmed the limited forces in
situ. However, an improvement was felt when the Government imposed a state
of emergency and a curfew as well as undertaking all possible measures to
curb the violence, including:
13