UN Forum on Minority Issues — "Minorities and Effective Political Participation"— Geneva 12-13 Nov. 2009
Mrs. Chairperson, thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to point out some
issues.
Concerning the Political Participation of Minorities in the Balkan States, focused on
Macedonarmans, known also as Macedo-Vlachs, Vlachs, one of the oldest European
peoples, living in their historical motherland, the ancient Macedonia, nowadays
—Greece, Albania, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Bulgaria and also in
Romania(in diaspora) — after Macedonia was devided (1913, after the Balkan War), I
prepared a powerpoint presentation which has been sent to the Secretariat of the forum.
I just want to point out some concluding remarks regarding unrecognized minorities, who
are excluded from political processes. These minorities are prevented to exercise their
rights, to have access to all form of political decision-making, at all exesting levels, rights
which are focused in all International Standards and European Union Standards on minority
issues.
The non-recognition of "de facto" existent minorities, an obstacle to the effective
political participation, leads to the marginalization of these minorities and ultimately to the
exclusion from the political life. This point of view is also mentioned in the background
document on Minorities and Effective Political Participation by the independent expert on
minority issues, Mrs. Gay McDougall.
In this sense, the "best negative" example is Romania. The Romanian government, based on
its Government Decision H.R. 589 / 2001, in fact a vicious circle, refuses any dialogue on
this issue with the Macedonarman Community of Romania. Although, conform to the
Romanian Constitution, Art. 6 ( the right to identity ), the Macedonarman minority exists
"de facto", but it is "de jure" not recognized. Furthermore, that means a violation of all
International and European treaties with regard to minoriy issues, treaties that. they already
have signed and ratified.
The second issue I would like to point out, regards to the definition of "national
minority" made by Albanian government, considering national minority only that minority
who has a "kin state", this fact leads to discrimination and prevents a "non-kin state"
minority to enjoy all internationally established rights.
Concerning the EU Standards, it is indeed to appreciate the first legally binding reference
on minority rights in the history of the European Union, the text of the Constitutional
Treaty, that includes „the rights of persons belonging to minority groups", although
insufficient for a clear and real protection of minorities.
Even, each of the both legally Council of Europe documents, the Framework Convention
for the Protection *of National Minorities (FCNM) and the European Charter for Regional
or Minority Languages(ECRML), constitues only a passiv minority protection,
insufficient for the real protection of minorities; an active approach, that is what
minorities have been waiting for
Thanks for your attention !
I.Mantsu — President of Macedonarman Council