A/68/283
exploitation and fewer migrants’ rights violations. States would still have the
sovereignty to decide on the number of migrants they wish to admit. Global
migration governance should thus be seen as reclaiming sovereignty, not ceding it. 12
92. As stated by the European Commission, poorly managed migration has
detrimental effects. Promoting effective migration governance is essential to
maximise the positive and minimise the negative impacts of migration on
development. In the absence of effective governance, the costs of migration may be
significant. 13
E.
Need to base the institutional framework inside the United Nations
93. The Special Rapporteur is concerned that migration dialogues often take place
outside the United Nations and international human rights frameworks, with a focus
on the economic developmental and political aspects of migration, without properly
integrating human rights concerns. He is also concerned at the lack of accountability
of the Global Forum on Migration Development and regional consultative processes
due to the absence of detailed records of proceedings. While noting that the Global
Forum and regional consultative processes may be useful forums for informal
discussions between States, this is not sufficient to lead to any significant changes
or improvements relating to global migration governance. He thus remains
convinced that a strengthened institutional framework is needed in addition to these
informal forums. The number of international migrants is increasing, and a growing
number of vulnerable migrants are abused and exploited both in transit and
destination countries. Furthermore, globalization is likely to increase the scale of
international migration, which is already quite substantial with an estimate of more
than 232 million international migrants in the world.
94. Greater involvement on the part of the United Nations in the global debate on
migration seems difficult to achieve as long as the Global Forum on Migration and
Development remains the leading international forum to discuss migration as an
informal, non-binding, voluntary and government-led process focused on migration
and development without giving proper attention to the human rights of migrants.
Consequently, there is a need to bring the migration dialogue inside the United
Nations framework. The United Nations plays an important role as a forum for
international collaboration, with human rights as one of its pillars: it is capable of
embracing the extreme complexity of migration movements in all their dimensions.
Creating a new, United Nations-based institutional framework would not preclude
regional or bilateral agreements, processes or organizations outside the United
Nations from also dealing with migration.
__________________
12
13
18/26
Kathleen Newland, “The governance of international migration: mechanisms, processes and
institutions”, paper prepared for the Policy Analysis and Research Programme of the Global
Commission on International Migration, September 2005.
Communication from the European Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the
European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on maximizing
the development impact of migration, 21 May 2013.
13-42115