E/CN.4/1995/91
page 132
punishing all violations committed by State officials is important and the
Special Rapporteur likewise considers the promulgation of two Council of State
decrees, Nos. 144 and 147, to be a step forward, despite some legal
ambiguities and an apparent sensitivity to the outside world. The
Special Rapporteur regards these new regulations as transitional measures in a
process leading to gradual improvement. In this context, the Special
Rapporteur wishes to submit the following recommendations, based on a study of
Chinese legislation and the talks held on this subject with various people in
China.
With regard to the right of freedom to manifest one’s religion, the
Special Rapporteur recommends that amendments be made to the pertinent legal
texts, such as article 36 of the Constitution, so as to provide a
constitutional guarantee of respect for freedom to manifest one’s religion or
belief in accordance with article 1, paragraph 1, of the 1981 Declaration.
With regard to the right of persons under the age of 18 to freedom of
belief, the Special Rapporteur recommends that steps be taken to adopt a
provision explicitly mentioning this right, so as to ensure the requisite
compliance with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, especially
article 14, which was ratified by China on 2 March 1992.
The Special Rapporteur further recommends the adoption of a text
recognizing the right to freedom of belief and freedom to manifest one’s
belief for all, including members of the Communist Party and other
socio-political organizations.
With reference to places of worship, the Special Rapporteur recommends
that the notion of a "fixed place" (para. 2 of decree No. 145) be defined so
as to clarify legally the particular terms, conditions and restrictions
applying to worship at home. The Rapporteur recommends a more precise
definition of the criteria for the registration of places of worship,
especially the number of believers and the qualifications of members of
religious orders.
Lastly, with regard to religious freedom in general, the Special
Rapporteur recommends the introduction in the medium term of a law on
religious freedom, so as to harmonize all the pertinent legal texts, remedy
legal ambiguities and, in keeping with established international standards,
overcome the particular fears and sensitivities prompted by the distinction
between nationals and foreigners.
The Special Rapporteur was encouraged to note a political determination
to apply legislation and policy in the field of tolerance of and
non-discrimination against religion and belief, despite some practical
monitoring difficulties. In particular, some adjustment of traditions and
modes of behaviour seems to be needed if a new culture among administrative
and prison authorities is gradually to take shape. Of course, this aim cannot
be achieved in the immediate future. Nevertheless, the Chinese authorities
could begin by clearly showing the way to reduce and combat abnormal
situations and excesses. There is a risk that if an administration has
discretionary power of judgement, this can degenerate into arbitrariness.
Endeavours must therefore be made to ensure that progress in legislation on