A/HRC/48/75
establishing it through mere legislation, given that, historically, such legislation has been
repealed once the government administration changes.99
45.
Some constitutions recognize the pre-existence of indigenous peoples, such as that of
the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. In 2014, El Salvador modified article 63 of its
Constitution to recognize the existence and rights of indigenous peoples. In Asia, there are at
least five countries in which indigenous peoples are recognized, including in the Constitution
of the Philippines (1987), which is one of the most progressive. 100 However, such recognition
is considered to have had a very limited impact on indigenous peoples’ lives in the region. In
Sweden, since the constitutional reform undertaken in 2011, the Sami Council people have
been recognized in the Constitution of Sweden, which prescribes an obligation to promote
the maintenance and development of Sami Council culture and communities.101 Some States
have constitutional recognition of the right to participation in the State. The Constitution of
Paraguay establishes that indigenous peoples are guaranteed the right to participate in the
economic, social, political and cultural life of the country, in accordance, inter alia, with their
customary practices.102
46.
Constitutional recognition is not enough without secondary legislation to facilitate its
compliance. That is the case in El Salvador, where there is no law yet on the rights of
indigenous peoples to their territory, indigenous governance or cultural identity, as
fundamental elements of their autonomy, and attempts to draft such a law have lacked
adequate consultation. 103 Some States have adopted legislation on political participation,
including Paraguay (Law No. 6279). 104 Moreover, many laws have been enacted in the
Plurinational State of Bolivia (Autonomy Framework Act No. 031 of 2010), Colombia
(various laws that regulate participation) and Nicaragua (Statute of Autonomy of the Atlantic
Coast Regions, Act No. 28 of 1987). Legislation in Panama has established five indigenous
regions with high levels of autonomy.105 In the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, there is an
organic law on indigenous peoples and communities, as there is in the Russian Federation. 106
47.
States have adopted legislation to operationalize free, prior and informed consent as a
mechanism for achieving self-determination in all areas of indigenous life, from education,
language revitalization and health care to land issues and development.107 A recent example
is the decree of July 2019 of the Congo establishing procedures for the consultation and
participation of indigenous peoples in economic development projects, operationalizing
article 3 of Law No. 5-2011 on the promotion and protection of the rights of indigenous
populations. Free, prior, and informed consent is an integral component of exercising the
right to self-determination and may grant opportunities for States, third parties and
indigenous peoples to achieve some rebalancing of power and strengthened partnership.108
However, some indigenous peoples are wary of what is often the conflation of free, prior and
informed consent, when managed through the State, with the right to self-determination,
which has had unintended consequences for some indigenous peoples.109 For that reason, the
Expert Mechanism encourages States and the private sector to promote and respect
indigenous peoples’ own protocols, as an essential means of preparing the State, third parties
and indigenous peoples to enter into consultation and cooperation.110 Free, prior and informed
consent is only one element in the advancement of indigenous peoples’ right to full self-
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
14
Ibid.
See A/74/149.
Submission from Sweden.
Submission from the national human rights institution of Paraguay.
Submission from the national human rights institution of El Salvador; see also CERD/C/SLV/CO/1819.
Submission from the national human rights institution of Paraguay.
Submission from the International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs.
See A/HRC/15/37/Add.5.
See A/HRC/39/62; and submission from Ecuador.
See E/C.19/2005/3; and submission from New Zealand.
Presentation made by Megan Davis at the expert seminar convened by the Expert Mechanism in
February 2021.
See A/39/62.