A/HRC/43/48/Add.1
a decrease from 439 in 2015) and human rights monitors in the country, 74 including
vandalism and harassment. Although research demonstrates that Muslims rarely report
incidents of discrimination, 75 official statistics submitted to the Special Rapporteur show
that 66 per cent (202) of these incidents in 2018 and 31 per cent (190) in 2017 were
motivated by anti-Muslim attitudes.
60.
The Special Rapporteur heard reports of Muslims being portrayed as terrorists in the
media and that such portrayals were generating mistrust among these communities. Many
claimed to believe, for example, that their communities are constantly under surveillance
and prone to frequent harassment. Muslims’ beliefs and practices have received
disproportionate public attention in recent decades, constituting a central theme for the
Party for Freedom, which holds 13.3 per cent of lower house seats and whose leader deems
Islam “the biggest problem in the Netherlands”. 76 In the run-up to the 2017 elections, he
declared, “if we don’t do something right now, the Netherlands will soon be an Islamic
country”, a statement accompanied by a provocative call for a Prophet Muhammad cartoon
contest and calls from fellow Party for Freedom politicians for all mosques to be closed. 77
Mr. Wilders was found guilty of insult and incitement to discrimination on racial grounds
for his comment that he would “take care” of having “fewer Moroccans in the country”. He
was acquitted of incitement to hatred and the Court imposed no punishment. Both Mr.
Wilders and the Public Prosecutor appealed the judgment. 78 Forum for Democracy, a new
party positioning itself as a moderate version of the Party for Freedom, became the largest
party in the 2019 provincial elections. The parliamentary group leader for Forum for
Democracy in the Senate, Paul Cliteur, has critiqued the architecture of mosques as
“intentionally provocative” and highlighted difficulties in guaranteeing safety for citizens
critical of Islam in his book Theoterrorism v. Freedom of Speech. 79 Members of the
Patriotic Europeans Against the Islamisation of the West political movement have
periodically staged protests outside mosques, some of which have involved pork barbecues.
61.
The growth of anti-Muslim sentiment in Dutch society was frequently linked by
interviewees to the rise in terror incidents taking place across Europe and North America,
including the murder in 2004 of film-maker Theo van Gogh by Dutch Moroccan
Mohammed Bouyeri, allegedly for his film, Submission. Research has indicated that in
more than 600,000 Dutch news items in 2016 and 2017, the adjectives most used to
describe Muslims were “radical”, “extremist” and “terrorist”.80
62.
A 2017 survey found that Dutch Muslims’ feelings of attachment to the country
were the second lowest and that their trust in the police was the lowest in the 15 European
Union countries surveyed.81 Nearly two thirds of teachers surveyed in another study said
that they had witnessed incidents they regarded as discriminatory against Muslims in the
classroom and 61 per cent reported that they had witnessed harassment of or hostile
comments towards Muslims.82
63.
Moreover, Dutch dual nationals reported that their freedom of movement was often
limited by fears that travel to regions deemed to be security threats under the Acts on
nationality and on temporary administrative counter-terrorism would lead to revocation of
their Dutch citizenship. Muslim communities also raised concerns about the selectivity of a
Government programme requiring compulsory language training and integration courses
for foreign imams, which is not always required for other religious communities.
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
16
Meldpunt Internet Discriminatie received 67 reports of anti-Muslim online incidents (94 per cent of
religious cases) in 2018 and 185 in 2016 (98 per cent), a significant decrease on the 472 reports
received in 2015.
See www.spior.nl/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Rapport-Islamofobie-in-Zicht.pdf.
Damhuis, “The biggest problem in the Netherlands”.
See www.tweedekamer.nl/kamerstukken/plenaire_verslagen/kamer_in_het_kort/debat-over-een-doorturkije-gedicteerde-jihadpreek.
See www.equalitylaw.eu/downloads/3968-the-netherlands-wilders-found-guilty-of-insulting-a-groupand-incitement-to-discrimination-on-grounds-of-race-pdf-138-kb.
Damhuis, “The biggest problem in the Netherlands”.
European Commission against Racism and Intolerance, “ECRI report on the Netherlands”.
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, Second European Union Minorities and
Discrimination Survey.
Stremmelaar and Lucassen, Antisemitism and Immigration in Western Europe Today.