A/HRC/43/48/Add.1
towards persons on the basis of religion or belief. Interlocutors who met with the Special
Rapporteur frequently highlighted increasing intolerance towards the public manifestation
of religion or belief by adherents of various religious communities in recent years, which
makes it more difficult for the country to uphold its obligations under the Declaration.
(a)
Pressures on the public manifestation of religion or belief
34.
Fifty-one per cent of the Dutch population identify as having no religion, which is
an increase on the estimated figure of 39 per cent in 2008. 32 An increasingly small number
of traditional Dutch churches have thriving congregations, while “new” religious norms
within diversifying communities are increasing. The Netherlands Institute for Social
Research (Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau) found that Dutch Muslims’ religious practice
had increased between 2006 and 2015, with those praying five times a day increasing from
72 per cent to 85 per cent, and from 69 per cent to 75 per cent for Turkish and Moroccan
Muslim communities respectively. 33 The number of women with Moroccan roots wearing a
headscarf has increased by 14 per cent; 89 per cent of those women currently wear a
headscarf. Moreover, faith was found to constitute the most important social identity factor
for Dutch Muslims.34 This shift has generated increasing debate on the role of religion in
relation to health care, education and asylum, for example, and calls for religious
restrictions to ensure security and protect core “Dutch values”, including freedom of
expression.
35.
Discussions are under way in the country about whether to adopt a stricter form of
secularity and about limiting the manifestation of “outdated” religious beliefs and practices.
Municipal buildings are designated as neutral spaces, with some municipalities taking an
exclusive rather than inclusive approach to the meaning of neutral. Some religious
interlocutors reported to the Special Rapporteur that their activities were prohibited in some
municipal buildings because belief in God was invoked in their events. Weekly services in
Rotterdam community centres have been discontinued, 35 and funding for Islam classes for
low-income children in Amsterdam has been cut. 36 Others report an unwillingness to
advertise or fund key aspects of interfaith events, even when they are supported by the
municipality. Religious leaders have been denied solidarity visits to asylum centres run by
the Central Agency for the Reception of Asylum Seekers, and students, including members
of a Christian association, reported to the Special Rapporteur that they had experienced
difficulties in being granted space for religious activity such as prayer. In 2019, the
Government updated its guidelines on religion in the public sphere, which are a useful tool
for municipalities, providing them with legal and practical guidance in their contacts with
religious organizations. The updated guidelines were due to be made public on 7 February
2020 during a seminar attended by representatives of religious communities, civil servants
and legal practitioners.
36.
In 2011, a provision was included in the Dutch Police Code of Conduct banning the
wearing of religious symbols with the uniform to ensure a neutral, more authoritative
appearance when interacting with the public. There is increasing debate about the need for
other government officials to maintain a neutral appearance. In November 2017, the
Netherlands Institute for Human Rights determined that the Dutch police’s decision to
prevent female officers from wearing headscarves amounted to indirect discrimination on
religious grounds.37
37.
Concern about the normalization of discourse that advances a “superior” Dutch
national identity and stigmatizes certain communities was frequently raised with the Special
Rapporteur. While not specifically defined, “Dutch values”, sometimes linked to a Judaeo32
33
34
35
36
37
10
CBS, “Over half of the Dutch population are not religious”.
Willem Huijnk, De religieuze beleving van moslims in Nederland (Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau,
Den Haag, 2018).
Willem Huijnk and others, Werelden van verschil (Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau,
Den Haag, 2015).
See www.trouw.nl/religie-filosofie/rotterdam-verbiedt-kerk-in-buurthuis~b16b7f3c/.
See www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/gemeente-amsterdam-stopt-met-vergoedenislamles~b82953c0/.
See www.equalitylaw.eu/downloads/4511-the-netherlands-nihr-regards-an-overall-headscarf-ban-forpolice-officers-as-discriminatory-pdf-135-kb.