A/75/183
Legislation and policies that prohibit the use of immigration detention of
all children
35. Some countries unconditionally prohibit the use of immigration detention of all
children in their legislative and policy frameworks. In Ireland, the International
Protection Act 2015 specifically prohibits the detention of any applicant for
international protection under the age of 18. There is no provision for the detention
of minors for immigration-related reasons in Irish legislation. 25
36. In Colombia, Nicaragua, Peru and Uruguay, migrant children are not detained
on the basis of their migration status. 26 In Central and South America, immigration
detention is considerably less prevalent than elsewhere. 27 In Costa Rica, for example,
the Decree on the Regulation of Refugees emphatically prohibits the detention of all
children regardless of whether they are accompanied or unaccompanied. In the
Dominican Republic, the Regulation of the General Law on Migration specific ally
prohibits the detention of migrant children. 28
37. Other countries have gone beyond the prohibition of detention of children for
migration-related purposes. They provide migrant children with enhanced protection
by ensuring adequate and prompt referral to child protection services. In Ecuador, the
Human Mobility Law prohibits immigration detention of children. The law also
guarantees the protection of the right to personal liberty for parents or caregivers,
implementing alternatives for the family, if it is in the best interests of the child to
maintain family unity. 29
38. Various countries on the African continent grant freedom of movement to their
citizens, including the member States of the Southern African Development
Community and the Economic Community of West African States. 30 In this context
of non-criminalization of migration, countries such as Kenya and South Africa also
have national legislation prohibiting the immigration detention of children. 31
39. In addition to explicit prohibition provided in national legislation, in Asia,
several countries have recently enacted policies committing to end or sharply reduce
detention of migrant children. For instance, in January 2019, several Thai agencies
signed a memorandum of understanding stipulating the respective responsibilities and
putting measures in place to provide social services and alternative care for migrant
children under the age of 18. 32 Similarly, in 2018, Indonesia developed a policy
pledging that refugees, including children with their families and unaccompanied or
separated children, should no longer be detained but rather be allowed to live
independently in shelters or community accommodation centres. 33 Although further
efforts are necessary to ensure an effective and systematic implementation, these
initiatives represent a significant first step towards ending the immigrat ion detention
of children.
__________________
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
20-09734
Submission by Ireland, and sect. 20 (6) of the International Protection Act 2015 of Ireland.
Submissions by Colombia and by the Nicaragua Ombudsman.
United Nations Global Study on Children Deprived of Liberty, pp. 460–462.
Dominican Republic, Reglamento de Aplicación de la Ley General de Migración, 2004.
Submission by the Public Defender of Rights of Ecuador.
International Detention Coalition, There are alternatives: Africa (Melbourne, Australia, 2018).
Available at https://idcoalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/There-are-alternatives-Africa2018.pdf.
Submission by the Refugee Consortium of Kenya.
Submission by the Permanent Mission of Thailand to the United Nations.
Submission by Indonesia.
9/23