A/75/183
Committee on the Rights of the Child has clearly stated that immigration detention of
any child is a violation of children’s rights and always contravenes the principle of
the best interests of the child. 5 This position has been affirmed by joint general
comment No. 4 (2017) of the Committee on the Protection of the Rights of All
Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families/No. 23 (2017) of the Committee on
the Rights of the Child on State obligations regarding the human rights of children in
the context of international migration in countries of origin, transit, destination and
return.
17. Several special procedures mandate holders have also stressed that immigration
detention of children should be prohibited (A/HRC/39/45, annex, para. 11,
A/HRC/37/50, para. 73, and A/HRC/30/37, para. 46).
18. In addition, several United Nations human rights mechanisms have emphasized
that children should never be criminalized or subject to punitive measures, such as
detention, because of their or their parents’ migration status (see CMW/C/GC/4CRC/C/GC/23). Immigration detention of children can never be understood as
compliant with the child’s best interests, not even as a measure of last resort, as there
are always non-custodial solutions available (A/74/136, para. 91). 6
19. A great number of initiatives and efforts demonstrate that there is an
international momentum towards eliminating immigration detention of children.
Member States made concrete commitments to work towards ending the practice of
child detention for the purposes of determining migration status when adopting the
New York Declaration for Refugees and Migrants (General Assembly resolution 71/1,
para. 33).
20. Building upon these efforts, and with the adoption of the Global Compact for
Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration, States committed to work to end the practice of
child detention in the context of international migration by ensuring the availability
and accessibility of a viable range of non-custodial alternatives that are in line with
international law (General Assembly resolution 73/195, annex, para. 29).
21. Furthermore, the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development provides an
overarching impetus for action to end violence against c hildren and to leave no child
behind. To fully realize Sustainable Development Goal target 16.2, which pledges to
end violence against children, States must address issues of st ructural violence, abuse
and denial of essential services that children often face in immigration detention. This
includes developing and implementing human rights-based non-custodial solutions,
and in connection with Goal target 10.7 on facilitating order ly, safe, regular and
responsible migration, calls for planned and well-managed migration policies.
22. The human rights of children have neither nationality nor borders. In addition
to the right to liberty, all children, without distinction, discriminatio n or exception,
are entitled to all the rights of the child as protected under international human rights
law, including the Convention of the Rights of the Child (see also CRC/GC/2005/6).
The child’s right to non-discrimination includes the protection of children against all
forms of discrimination and punishment, specifically on the basis of the status of the
child and his or her parents or family members. The irregular situation in which
migrant children and their families may find themselves does not deprive them of
their humanity or their human rights, including their economic, social and cultural
__________________
5
6
20-09734
Committee on the Rights of the Child, “Report of the 2012 day of general discussion”, para. 32.
Available at www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/CRC/Discussions/2012/DGD2012Report
AndRecommendations.pdf.
See also Inter-American Court of Human Rights, advisory opinion OC-21/14, “Rights and
Guarantees of Children in the Context of Migration and/or in Need of International Protection ”,
19 August 2014.
5/23