A/76/162
sweeping changes in part to further expand “tourism development”: these changes
include the draft Lakshadweep Development Authority Regulation, 2021, changing
property rights to allow the expropriation of land “for development”, the demolition
of traditional fisher sheds, the development of tourism resorts, the freeing up of
alcohol sales and restrictions on raising of cattle and consumption of beef, without
any consultation or agreement with the Muslim inhabitants of the territory, who make
up more than 96 per cent of its population.
74. From a human rights point of view, and consistent with the warning issued in
the United Nations/World Bank Group report on inclusive approaches to preventing
violent conflict, the development measures described above appear to have
discriminated against indigenous and other minorities, with employment, profits and
benefits funnelled mainly towards central authorities and with native minorities
receiving little or no benefits, and in some cases massive damage to their local
environment, dislocation and even increased poverty. In other words, development in
these and many other cases may increase horizontal inequalities unless States are fully
aware of the consequences of development on minorities and take active steps to
measure the impact of development efforts on minorities and indigenous peoples, who
may be more susceptible to systemic marginalization in many societies.
75. Unfortunately, almost none of the measures or indicators of the Sustainable
Development Goals currently acknowledge or provide for the identification and
measurement of the risks of growing horizontal inequalities throug h development,
and therefore omit to address how to leave no one behind through shared and equal
prosperity for these often-excluded communities. Instead of inclusive growth being a
priority, development can exacerbate exclusion and marginalization that ri sks being
invisible, and lead to tensions, growing inequality and the maintenance of systemic
discrimination against minorities and indigenous peoples. 48 Even more unacceptable
is the disregard of the situation of minority women, which needed particular at tention
in the area of economic development impact. The intersection of discrimination on
the basis of gender and ethnicity, religion or language needed to be considered
systematically in development efforts. Instead, despite it being well established that
women from marginalized populations, such as minorities and indigenous
communities, are the overwhelming number of those excluded from the benefits of
development initiatives and living in poverty worldwide, minority women are largely
omitted and invisible in the data and measurements of progress of the 2030 Agenda.
IV. Concluding remarks and recommendations
76. A human rights-based approach requires greater focus in the Sustainable
Development Goals and their measures and indicators on the marginalized, most
disadvantaged and excluded groups in order to reduce disparities and horizontal
inequalities where most needed. Such an approach would require that efforts and
resources target the most vulnerable and excluded groups. There cannot be
equality for all if no attempt is made to measure the inequalities that already
exist, especially for the most marginalized groups in terms of participation in
social and economic development. Among the most marginalized are minorities,
particularly minority women.
77. While the 2030 Agenda and measures and indicators of the Sustainable
Development Goals made impressive leaps forward with the prioritization of
gender issues and the importance of measuring progress towards the Goals
through gender-disaggregated data, critically, the absence of disaggregation on
__________________
48
21-09902
Ibid.
19/22