E/CN.4/2006/16
page 11
The need to promote a dual strategy in combating racism: a political and legal strategy to
combat its political, economic and social manifestations and expressions, and an
intellectual and ethical strategy to eradicate its deep roots linked to value systems,
identity constructs, the recording and teaching of history, and to education.
II. CONTEMPORARY MANIFESTATIONS OF RACISM,
RACIAL DISCRIMINATION, XENOPHOBIA AND
RELATED INTOLERANCE
28.
In this part of the report the Special Rapporteur wishes to draw the Commission’s
attention to particularly alarming problems and manifestations of racism, racial discrimination
and xenophobia. Such manifestations as Islamaphobia and the activities of neo-Nazi groups are
dealt with in separate reports, the report on the question of the situation of Arab and Muslim
populations in various parts of the world (E/CN.4/2006/17) and the report on political platforms
which promote or incite racial discrimination (E/CN.4/2006/54), respectively.
A. Multiculturalism and racism
29.
The problem of multiculturalism, its recognition, its management and its social, political
and economic dynamic, is an underlying factor and the central issue in present-day crises in most
of the regions of the world. The current crisis in the suburbs of France reveals the social and
cultural depths of multiculturalism. The question of discrimination involves the multicultural
process in two broad dimensions. The more visible, political, economic and social dimension, is
characterized by the correspondence between the map of marginalization and the ethnic, racial or
religious map of a multicultural society. But, at root, the identity issue in the multicultural
process is illustrated by efforts to counter discrimination in the arenas of memory and value
systems. This dimension, often overlooked by political leaders, reveals the need for a cultural
and ethical strategy to eradicate racism and discrimination from multicultural societies.
30.
Multicultural societies are the outcome of lengthy historical processes involving contact
between peoples, cultures and religions. These encounters and intermixings have taken place
within societies whose progressive development has, over the course of history, produced an
organizational and operational framework, the nation. The organizing mechanism for this
structure is generally based on a factor for recognition and cohesion and unity: the national
identity. The correlation or link between two concepts, identity and nation, has resulted, through
the processes of the construction of identify over time on the basis of history, memory, language,
culture and religion, in the structuring of most modern societies by the political and legal concept
of the nation State. The nation State concept has, in general, been intellectually and
ideologically conceived and implemented politically as the expression of a national identity
reflecting, depending on the political context, on an exclusive basis, an ethnic group, a religion
or a culture. The central problem of most modern societies lies in the fundamental contradiction
between the framework of the nation State, the expression of an exclusive national identity, and
the dynamic of multiculturalization at work in those societies.
31.
The cultural, ethnic or religious diversity of communities, groups and peoples brought
together through various historical processes always results in an encounter between different
identities. The circumstances attending that encounter, discovery, conquest or domination
determine the way in which this diversity is perceived: attraction, rejection, fear, hostility. The