A/HRC/10/11/Add.3
page 22
the minority status of other communities, stating that those claims are unsubstantiated and
politically motivated. To some degree, however, the government seems concerned that such
recognition would ipso facto implicate the foreign policy of the Greek state toward a
neighboring state.
82. One also senses an interest in promoting a singular national identity. This approach
may leave little room for diversity. It can contribute to a climate in which citizens who wish
to freely express their ethnic identities face government blockages and in some instances,
intimidation from other individuals or groups. In the northern part of the country some
people expressed their view that the term “minority” implies “foreign.” Some consider
those who want to identify as a person belonging to a minority ethnic group to be
conspirators against the interest of the Greek state.
83. Greece recognizes only one minority, that is the Muslim Religious Minority in
Western Thrace, which is protected by the terms and protocols of the 1923 Treaty of
Lausanne which also provides reciprocally for the protection of the Greek Orthodox
minority living in Turkey. Matters relating to the Muslim minority and the full observance
and implementation of the Treaty of Lausanne, are handled by the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs. While members of the Muslim minority are fully citizens of Greece, Turkey is
allowed to have a Consulate in the region of Western Thrace and to involve itself in matters
relating to the Muslim minority relevant to the Treaty of Lausanne.
84. Greece does not recognize differing ethnic or linguistic minorities, although it
acknowledges that groups, like the Roma, are disadvantaged or vulnerable groups. So,
Roma (those who are not Muslims), Muslims who are not from Western Thrace, those who
claim a Macedonian ethnicity and more recent but settled immigrant communities are
limited with respect to the full enjoyment of their rights of self-identification and the
particular enhanced protections that they may be due as minorities. Muslims in Western
Thrace face limitations on the full enjoyment of their right to have their Turkish ethnicity
acknowledged. Further, those who identify as belonging to an ethnic Macedonian minority
face social pressures and a challenge to their motives by the government. Associations have
been denied registration because their desired name includes the words “Turkish” or
“Macedonian.” Their rights to freedom of expression and freedom of association as
protected under Article 19 and Article 22 of the ICCPR respectively have been infringed.
85. In both Western Thrace and the region of Central and West Macedonia, the debate
over issues of recognized identities has been contentious. Tensions persist and there have
been credible reports of intimidation.
86. While noting the historical origins of the Greek government’s obligations toward the
Muslim minority in Western Thrace and the political history of the Balkans, the
Independent Expert urges Greece to consider its obligations with respect to minority
populations as arising within the post-1945 legal framework of modern human rights
treaties and jurisprudence based on the principle that protection of human rights and