Mrs. Chairperson, thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to point out some issues
I would first like to point out some issues regarding the use of the term „minority“. When we talk about
„minorities“ it is necessary to make a difference between minorities :
- firstly, there are minorities with a kin – state, minorities which are supported and encouraged by these
states they live in;
- secondly, there are minorities which never establish their own state, an example is the Macedonarman
people in Balkan countries, one of the oldest people in Europe with deepest roots in Antique
Macedonia. This ethnic people feel themselves discriminated, for example in Greece, when they are
considered a minority, they are actually autochthonous there. The Macedonarman people have their
own language and culture, but have no access to education in their own language – nowhere – neither in
Grece, nor in Albania, nor in FYROM (R. Of Macedonia), nor in Bulgaria, nor in Romania.
Therefore, I would suggest for the Draft Recommendation to point out clearly the term autochthonous
people and especially, people without an own state.
I would also suggest for the Draft Recommendation, to accurately define the term “dialect – language”.
There are states which do not support national minorities or do not even recognize ethnic groups as
minorities, considering that these minorities speak a dialect of the majority language and could not be
therefore considered a minority. An example in this direction is Romania, where the macedonarman
people constitutes an immigrant minority. Their language is though related to the Romanian Language,
also a Romance Language, but the Arman (Macedonarman) people is distinct from the Romanian
people.
The Council of Macedonarmans, established by many Arman communities from Balkan countries and
registered as a legal entity with the Department of Justice in Tirana, Albania, is particularly preoccupied
by gaining recognition for the Armâns, in each Balkan country, where they have been living organized in
communities since time immemorial, as a distinct, autochthonous, and regional people, who speak their
own millenary language dating back to the ancient Macedonia.
Considering the critical situation of the Armâns (Macedonarmâns) in all above – mentioned Balkan
countries and the silence of the institutions from these countries regarding the acces of this people to the
education in their own language, we will greatly appreciate an expertise made by the Independent Expert
on Minority Issues and find practical and judicial solutions for that.
Thanks for your attention !
I.Mantsu
e-mail : mantsu@t-online.de
Tel. 0049-174 900 21 03
President of the Council of Macedonarmans
Head Office Voskopoje-Korce-Po.Box 54, Korce, Albania