A/HRC/61/49/Add.1
14.
The Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination has stated the following:
The term “non-discrimination” does not signify the necessity of uniform treatment
when there are significant differences in situation between one person or group and
another, or, in other words, if there is an objective and reasonable justification for
differential treatment. To treat in an equal manner persons or groups whose situations
are objectively different will constitute discrimination in effect, as will the unequal
treatment of persons whose situations are objectively the same. The Committee has
also observed that the application of the principle of non-discrimination requires that
the characteristics of groups be taken into consideration.3
15.
Therefore, special measures must be adopted when circumstances warrant, to secure
for disadvantaged groups the full and equal enjoyment of human rights and fundamental
freedoms.4 In addition, the principle of non-discrimination cannot be fully implemented if
efforts are not grounded in the recognition and valuing of cultural diversity. In this regard,
for example, educational policies promoting the Lao language at the expense of minority
languages should be reassessed.
16.
In addition, it is important to consider that indirect discrimination may affect specific
groups, for example when resettlement policies affect highland communities more
significantly.
C.
Recognition of ethnic groups and non-recognition of minorities and
Indigenous Peoples
17.
There are 50 ethnic groups recognized in the country, belonging to four linguistic
groups: Mon-Khmer, Lao-Tai, Sino-Tibetan and Hmong-Iu Mien. This classification was
established on the basis of research conducted by the Institute of Anthropology and Religions
Research together with the department of ethnic affairs under the Lao Front for National
Construction and the ethnic affairs committee of the National Assembly; the work was
endorsed by the National Assembly in December 2008. The study recognized 49 groups; a
fiftieth was recently added. Although formally abolished in 2008 – on the basis that it was
hierarchical and divisive – another system, which categorizes the population into three groups
(Lao Soung, Lao Theung and Lao Loum) based on geography (upper highlands, midlands
and lowlands, respectively) is used widely in practice, including by the Government.
18.
Recognizing the diversity of the Lao people is an important step, and is crucial to
ensuring cultural rights. The Special Rapporteur worries however that the principle of
self-identification – how each individual identifies with a particular group, as well as how
each group determines its own affiliation – seems to be lacking in recognition processes. She
also understands that the 50 ethnic groups contain even greater diversity, with estimates of
the number of subgroups ranging from 160 to 200.
19.
One difficulty lies in the refusal of the Lao People’s Democratic Republic to recognize
ethnic minorities or Indigenous Peoples on its territory, referring to “ethnic groups” only, a
term that actors operating in the country are compelled to use. The refusal is rooted in the
need to avoid discrimination between groups and divisions in society and, with regard to
Indigenous Peoples, the view that no group came first. The concept of Indigenous, however,
is not about priority but rather historical continuity. The State recognizes all ethnic groups as
equal components of the Lao nation.
20.
It is obvious to the Special Rapporteur that many groups in the country fulfil the
criteria for being considered as ethnic minorities or Indigenous Peoples, including strong
connections with communal lands, forests and rivers. Those groups need specific attention,
as they often find themselves in a marginalized position. Despite the non-discrimination
discourse put forward by the authorities, the Special Rapporteur heard many interlocutors
describing the prejudice against highland communities. Indeed, in conversations between the
Special Rapporteur and the authorities, such communities were often described, sometimes
3
4
4
General recommendation No. 32 (2009), para. 8.
Ibid., para. 11.
GE.26-01463