E/CN.4/2003/85
page 3
In particular, there is a tendency to provide immigration officials with broad powers to detain
groups of migrants in conditions and facilities that seriously curtail their right to judicial or
administrative review of the lawfulness of detention and to have their asylum claims reviewed.
Migrants subjected to administrative proceedings have in general far fewer guarantees
and rights than those who are the subject of judicial proceedings. Legal grounds for
administrative detention of migrants are often too broad and discretional and time limits are not
always legally determined or respected. This is often coupled with the absence of automatic
mechanisms for judicial or administrative review and with a lack of other procedural safeguards,
such as access to interpreters and lawyers, and limitations on the right to be informed of the
grounds for detention and appeal mechanisms and the right to have consular or embassy
representatives informed. All these elements result in administrative detention being beyond any
control, disproportionate powers being exercised by immigration authorities, and incidents of
discrimination and abuse.
Legislation and practices allow administrative detention to become at times indefinite or
very lengthy, despite the fact that the facilities built or used for this purpose are not equipped for
long-term detention. They do not provide for access to education, recreational activities and
adequate medical services. According to the information received, many migrant holding
centres are overcrowded and conditions of detention do not respect international norms,
standards and principles, and at times amount to inhumane or degrading treatment. Often, such
facilities are not accessible to external mechanism of inspection and grievance, or complaint
mechanisms do not exist or are not accessible. The general lack of external oversight and human
rights training permits torture, abuses and ill-treatment to take place.
Undocumented migrants deprived of their liberty often do not receive adequate legal,
medical, social and psychological assistance and protection, either by the institutions of the host
countries or by their consular representatives. Consular posts often lack the necessary
equipment, personnel and expertise. In several cases, owing to the lack of documents, migrants
are not recognized as citizens by their consulates or embassies.
With particular regard to the information received and reflected in the report, the Special
Rapporteur would recommend that infractions of immigration laws and regulations not be
considered criminal offences under national legislation; Governments should consider the
possibility of progressively abolishing all forms of administrative detention and, when this is not
possible, take measures to ensure respect for the human rights of migrants deprived of liberty.
The Special Rapporteur would like to encourage Governments to ensure that consular
and embassy personnel are adequately trained to provide assistance to nationals in distress
abroad, including irregular migrants. Mechanisms of supervision of cases of negligence in
providing such assistance should exist. The Special Rapporteur would also like to underline that
such assistance should be provided through the presence of representatives of all relevant
ministries and departments, as well as through specialized medical, social and psychological
counselling, at least in those countries with a high incidence of migration.