L.
f!nmrnuTiieation Ho. 293/1988, Horace Hihhart v. Jamaica (views
arinpt-.ttfl on 27 July 1992, at the fortv-fifth session)
Submitted bvt
Horace Hibbert (represented by counsel)
Alleged victim:
The author
party:
Jamaica
Date of communication:
24 January 1988
nat-.e of decision on admissibility.!
19 October 1989
The Human Bights Committee, established under article 28 of the
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights,
Meeting on 27 July 1992,
Having concluded its consideration of communication Ho. 293/1988,
submitted to the Human Rights Committee by Mr. Horace Hibbert under the
Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Bights,
Having tahen into account all written information made available to it by
the author of the communication and by the State party,
its views under article 5, paragraph 4, of the Optional Protocol.
Facts as submit-.t-.ftrl by the author
1,
The author of the communication is Horace Hibbert, a Jamaican citizen
currently awaiting execution at St. Catherine District Prison, Jamaica, He
claims to be a victim of violations by Jamaica of article 14 of the
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. He is represented by
counsel.
2.1 The author was a corporal in the police force of Jamaica and formerly
assigned to the Morant Bay Constabulary Station in the parish of Saint James.
In the late evening of 11 June 1984, he was assigned to special duty in the
district of Prospect with three other officers from the Morant Bay Station, to
search for a notorious local criminal who was wanted on a charge of burglary
and larceny. He states that it was in performance of his duties that, on the
night in question, he shot two individuals, Maureen Robinson and Leroy Sutton,
who had been approaching the police vehicle around which the police officers
were gathering. Ms. Robinson died instantly, whereas Mr. Sutton was paralysed
by a bullet fired from the author's 0.38 calibre service weapon) he died in
December 1985. The police investigation established that the other police
officers and a third person, who had been interrogated by them, had seen
Ms. Robinson and Mr. Sutton, that one of the officers told them to return to
their homes on account of the advanced hour and that they had been sitting
next to the police car for five minutes. The author, however, claims that he
saw them for the first time when their bodies were placed in the trunk of the
car.
2.2
The author submits that just before discharging the fatal shots, he had
-284-