E/CN.4/1991/56
page 32
Section 1 first paragraph of the Act which lists the conditions for
exemption, reads as follows: 'If there is reason to assume that a conscript
is unable to perform military service of any kind without coming into conflict
with his serious convictions, he shall be exempted from such service by the
competent ministry or by judgment pronounced pursuant to the provisions of
this Act.'
Each year there are some 2,000-2,500 applications for exemption pursuant
to the Act. The Ministry of Justice, which is the competent ministry, grants
approximately 80 per cent of these applications. About 40 per cent of the
remaining cases are brought before a court, and some 80 per cent of these
applicants are also exempted.
Those who are exempted from military service in accordance with the
above-mentioned Act are required to perform compulsory civilian service."
Romania
"The Constitution in our country is being prepared on the basis of new
principles. Previous legislation severely penalized those who refused to
perform military service. Today, even before the new Constitution has been
prepared, the Government of Romania has decided that theological students are
exempt from military service".
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
"There is no compulsory military service in St. Vincent and the
Grenadines."
Sweden
"On the issue of the right to conscientious objection I should like to
refer to the information presented on these issues in the note of the Swedish
Government of 20 December 1989 regarding resolution 1989/59 of the Commission
on Human Rights, entitled 'Conscientious objection to military service'. A
copy of the note is enclosed for your convenience."
Swedish military defence is based on general conscription for men. The
Act on Compulsory Military Service (1941:967) has the character of a general
compulsory law which clearly prescribes that Swedish men from 18 to 47 years
of age are liable for military service and may be called up for training and
other service. There are few exceptions to the general rule that all Swedish
men are liable for military service. Exemption from carrying out military
service may be granted for physical and/or mental reasons. In addition, by
virtue of the Act on Non-combatant Service (1966:413), there are possibilities
for persons liable for military service to perform non-combatant service
instead of military service.
According to Section 1 of the Act on Non-combatant Service, this service
may be performed instead of military service "if it can be assumed that the
use of weapons against another person is so irreconcilable with the serious
personal convictions of the conscript that he will not fulfil his military
service."