E/CN.4/1991/56
page 31
use of arms (...) shall instead render substitute service outside the Federal
Armed Forces in accordance with Article 12a (2) of the Basic Law (section I of
the Conscientious Objectors Act)'.
'Recognized conscientious objectors who
render civilian service are required to do work which serves the general
public, especially in the social sphere' (section I, Civilian Service Act).
In lieu of civilian service recognized conscientious objectors may also work
in a development or charitable or relief service abroad. Thus no one may be
compelled to do military service, but those who refuse are required to
complete a period of substitute civilian service, usually in the social field."
"In Greece, the question of conscientious objection to military service
is regulated by Law 763 of 1988, which offers an alternative, weaponless,
military service of double the duration of normal service. The additional
weaponless military service is in conformity with the European Convention of
Human Rights of 1950 (article 4, para. 3 b ) . "
Grenada
"There is no compulsory military service in Grenada."
Iraq
"This does not pose a problem in Iraq, since the performance of military
service is an honour for all citizens, who have a legal obligation to perform
it."
"There is no compulsory military service in Malta."
Mexico
"The Mexican Constitution establishes in article 31 that it is an
obligation of Mexicans 'To attend, on such days and at such times as the
municipality in which they live may prescribe, in order to receive civic and
military training ... '. Military training in Mexico is generally done under
a highly flexible system, unlike other countries, where the system of military
billeting is compulsory. However, Mexican law does not provide for
conscientious objection to compulsory military service."
Nicaragua
"In Nicaragua there is no conscientious objection to compulsory military
service. At the present time, the Act regulating such service is suspended
and the intention is to waive it."
Norway
In its reply, the Government of Norway referred to this question as
follows:
"Norwegian provisions on the question of conscientious objection to
compulsory military service are set out in the Act of 19 March 1965 relating
to exemption from military service for reasons of personal conviction.